
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS



FOR THE SEVENTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS



AT AMARILLO



PANEL A



AUGUST 26, 2004



______________________________



NO. 07-04-0285-CV



IN RE EXXONMOBIL CORPORATION, ET AL., RELATORS



________________________________



NO. 07-04-0286-CV



IN RE CHEVRONTEXACO CORPORATION, ET AL., RELATORS



__________________________________



Before JOHNSON, C.J., and REAVIS and CAMPBELL, JJ.

CONCURRING OPINION

 The taxing units allege that the defendant companies engaged in a conspiracy and fraud to fix posted prices for oil.   However, because they did not seek relief under sections 15.05(c) and (h) and 15.21 of the Texas Business and Commerce Code Annotated, and without expressing any opinion whether these provisions may provide them a remedy, I concur in the decision of the majority opinion.

Don H. Reavis

      Justice	

