FH_ED lfN

 

`T`h'e Court of Appea|s
Q,i><th District
._ '~ _ -CE -~_
m b<p~~+ 00 ‘q* F M,.;”"L 1 62”'§
¢'). IS fl
1 ' 2015 _'IM `Y'\'\E S;LXT*'\ cloun 0 4 H'e,xa€r)k@na,, Tex'as
JUL a GA» “TQ>COJ`\CCM¥\ TTQXC~S ®"-e©rr°@ SK. Awtfrey, Ci|er€k
Te>car%c§ama, Texas \ "*
L`il"’s§§€az Au»trey, Clerk
'Y;er\r\`\€, :\_0¥\¥\5°‘“ APPQ_\\OA~\-
\f§.
\\Q,Q,
~Th€ g-rA~re orr ~rems A?PQ

 

‘ - ` Cow~\- 09
‘ ecL\ ‘Ff!>m +¥"°' D\%+GQ_
“_W \»M;Q. wm ' 'Y€z€~;&
\C)?_"`C3 judicio~\ D‘S

 

A\>\;>@\\cm*v`é Pm 51 36va

 

'FY>PJ\&\\`€ Q/z>\f\nw\ "/5"‘
QPPQ\\CU‘* P"`D `SQ'
TDQ:S N<>' ‘qq°°_§§
BOwO F;r\/\ 35"|4

rn()(\-\' T:€_.>(Q`S
E€ali 1 qqqo$__

IDENTI‘\'Y op FAR“H:ES
RMD Q,.OLLM$EL

/Pur~suo~n+ +Q ’T<axa§ Ru\e. 09 Rppe_llcd€~ D"QC€C\WE. 32’"(®
+he. ~Q@c>\-\w\m"n§_ \\'s‘r `\3 a ccmp\e:%c \\`)S-\~ 09 all {Dar)w&&

~+v …z wm o,@w+is \‘)ud@men+ and +he names
Omo\ addresses 0€'-¢1,\\ +\»\"4,\ ar\o\ Q|OFQHQ+Q QOu‘r\Sa\‘.

m P\am+s\°€, A\DPQ\\QQ,
%+a+z 09 mas

('.U '\De§`€hdan‘\‘, F\ppe\\&n‘\'
Berm\`e, :W>l_msm\ j"Sr.
C'B) D€§`f;ndam-'$ +r~`\`<L\ QounS€.\

W"~ Xv\m\ S‘Hv\xc\
5'5` “VY\a¢`n S+v“ce+
"l’&><ar|cam ,’Ce.><a$ r'|S'S"lsl

60 f\\>p@l\an+‘$ appe\\ed<. QW¥\S£\
"(‘(\r. 'Be_rr~\`c> S. *YY]O,FOJ|¢U\G|
§)L, P»`ne 5+#€.€+

P,D. 301 lDL//S’

/|_%)<Qr |Cana ,Te¢a_€ '7§:>'0\
LS`) S+GJ€/'S +r\ia,\ cmO aPPQl|a,+e, gounse,\

`YY\r`» j'€rr~\j RQQ,\¢\€ u€_,

PDOLO£Q, Qbur\\' . D\`S\-r\‘c,-\» 944anng O@Q"CE.
_ . §§
@OI ‘W\ac/W S+r€€"’

T€,Yarl<ama l"l'e><a$ '75'5’0 l

_°

TA BL\E - op coman“rs

"'Q

\c§e.n+l\~:><>£ %Mesanc\ er\§e\~--~' “ ‘ ‘ ' "
Tob\e 09 Qor\J¢QnJ<-S » » . 4 » ,. . . ,,,,, a ~» ~> '»
|r\C\U\ oil \qu-\»Y\or~\`¥§¥§es 4, 4 w o . ., 4 . _ .- ., -
S¥a+emen+ o~F ~)Jr)e Case 4 . . -» » .. .. ~ o ~ »
issues `Dr~es@n+e¢\ , . ., . 9 d . :, _., . 9
6403¢¢~\@+ mv traQ+g ., o d ., .» . z . .1-5

S\/mem`:z O'C` "_"\& A~\'E\,\{Y\ex\_\_ n o 4 c o " ‘ " 6|7
Ar€)ume,r\-\- ,_

§

`¢_, `

`§ -`\§
`_“

PH

o a ‘0 q °

o -o .. b ap 10 -o 9 0 o o

`\55“5 ONE 3 "Vhe, %\nc\e_nu :r_s EMQPF,‘C,Q,T+

___|`O SL\PPO"`+ _l`h€» COV\\/\Q,‘\‘\`GV\ C{`~ pg§rv.m-\~Qd @`/0
$@,xu&\ Hsscm\+,

lssue Two¢ C<>w\se| Tl¢ndeé@\ lne\@r-QQH\/Q

Ags\'s+om,wa, 1333 [;ajl{n§ "7;) provide CL

pmpu~ *T»~,'o_\ 5-)~"*4+ jj 53 DF€”"”’ `H?Q
"i‘i j

DOO,. per §X+mne,ou§ cpr-tense

II-/4

\SSUE THR£E .' Coun'$e| /Zender-ec\ Ine£@e¢(-i’\/@
H`S$iS"'OJ'\CJL. 63 Fw`l|.*'\é/ _TZ> :r\VQS-}~ijq;l-€_
pr\lr@»m+)`\/e [)MA.

Il-H

& F:Or` T\'\D'= SFVKE OF: CO'\)UE§.?§[Q§,ISS(AQ_ ""1:00
and 'The% wm 36 l_.‘l:,chz<d ~133,@#\€,._!
prag?€r` , a o 4 o o ,,\ a 4 , 4 9 * -¢ 5
@€»-HF/`<n}e 01@ §erw“mz .

.. ,l5
1 d 0 0 4 o ' J [6

_.
"

IMOEX OF AUTHOR`IT.IE$`

&ASE§ ~. ' _ "SGE

’Bm@_ v. 3+04€_ a
fm 3 00 iad 829 L*E>L,Qr~\'m.£lpp. 2002) 13

grown V. S\'OAQ q

z<g\ 3 00 3d s_@s~, 973 ( ma /-}Fp 500+100<! 20»2,2>°},€9
:D~Q_V\~\'or\ V. S"`CC\"Q,
q'¢\ 5,@, 00\ 332¢3<30 CT<x.Cr.'m,AFp. )¢)¢)0-) C?

jackson \/ \/'ij;& q
445 u 3 am 3m qq 3 c:+ msu ,,le)z_ edz</QM/@”J

`mljrd\@\\ V S'|-O}rQ
(p<g 5 w 36 (0’40 (Q‘)LLCT`Q)C Qmm. Q]OF 1003ng

Yobe\»¥sm u. aware

197 S.uD. '»Z>d '+'75', '-H<¢-~Sl» £TQ)€;~C’r/m v- QQ>P. 300€2 ) 14

S‘\’FFQ)<(QI)O) V LDQSH/Q§)con
LHQ¢» U 5 ,;QQ§§ 10¢ s c+ 2000 go 2 521 2d w¢z/%/</)i

"[Tbbs \/. Y:/or,`do. q
454 u.§. 3:,40~41, 102 5 a+ 2_\\ '7.2202 22/¢;$:>(/9?2)

@O¢`lh‘ams 12 3+4}¢ q
002 502 96 3#4,3%[1/<>¢.0~'/".¢1,@,¢,)223) l

S"/'r-\'mzzs

'l_¢><a§ ?er\@l C@d`». Sec‘;\w`m SJ»OQ~\ _’Z_.

STN\’E ME r\\'r o\= T\-\E cAs§

"TY\€S `\`S~ OJ\ &PPQ&\ P@m & Qgr\\r»`Q.+\`or\ P€)r f.ljjrm.a{€d
S©CU\ ASSM“` ;‘\ VFO\OJ`(O"‘ 09 "\`Qxas peno-J Code Ser'/or)
QQ~-Ol\ ' CL 'P\`FS‘\» GQ,SY'€_Q pe\onj , `,n .(_,»,`a\ QOU_M_ numbe.,_
\lpogl""°l O~“‘O\ &PP@\ number Db»l##~oc>)W-Q/a‘
€C.Q. Ob~-r¢-Oolq<,z~@z pj. '7<3 }_ QJ-UWJ +}>Md 33an
%u'\\*\§ ama assessed c2 punish,/he,,{_ 00 \,-§€,(Q'Q' %_
lLL~c>Ol‘?LL-Crz Pj, FISZ)(

155£1& pRESENTF_D
Issue One f "'WWQ %v¢`MaQL is :1;/,5 u,C\Ci@'@/q+ 7¢-0
51%00(~+ "The, cler)\/vc+;`z>n 09 HNm\/cded §€X¢W

prSgau|+`

I.ssue 'Two: Coum§eJ Henderwed Ine»£€€c:}#`\/Q Hssiyifihd.€:
53 F"`»;l’/fl&~ '_Ta provide proper 77’&) §+a,+€'j‘j bd
C>\>en.r% ~H\,L 'Door~ -)Q>Q €)<+m/)e`ous DFF€/)$Q .

:LSSUQ _rHRee: @vw)§e/ Rendm»_d ~:;:neq@§e@n./Q a§,sJQ/;@
Bj {:a¢]l`ng_ ;Lc :/:n\/e.j+/S@+L AI!O»GQHZ/@ D/\J//Tl,

STATEMEMT or F'Ae:rs

RS 6'-¥00\-¢<1 &bove, Qppe\\ar\`\~ was \`GO{\`Q+©\ i'/) @Qwe /Uo.
t?_FO§Q.|~-lbl For~ ~H)Q `F`€\on oPFQnSQ O-F ,L}jjm\/Q%€d
jC)CuQ\ GSSQMH~ [TOCQ~S Per)o_/ Ooc}€ 523.0>_1 j

Or\ opem`r\‘b` S~M+emen+s, /\/]r_ S+rzw@\, H°Hmme\,¢j

flow Qppel\an+ , 31`\/@5 a preview 09 ~|~he. defense 7%@
`H,\Q:, m qppel\a/l+ and %¢LQ C’OW)F/Q/`r?€d\+ fwqu
trw 0.0r\$€r\$u\€h\ S€><", (ZH \/ol. §7.‘/§]/¢»3

rDu/r\i r\é_ 0 pen O,c>uu~~\-

O\p?z.\\€u`v\~ 045 h\`$ f“\`%h~\~ ~+~o `\~€S+H\J- Q'=p+€r QdmOO\’Sh\`r\%Y ®'{“
'""5¥\'\`3;“\}’)’\€ ~PO\\Q\D'\N\B, ~\-o§\< \©\O\Q.Q, ' »

A

"\`»\e, er~+g ;,Q+ me 03/< %LS, 5000 .‘;'u>m+;s been

900 oa\)~ce +<> +>\~2 cle&n<wn+ `m +ws QQ§<; ab +O wham
OV l"\o+' .\'\€ Shou\<>\ +€.5+1"143 Or nm\~ ?

NY‘. S’h"oudx ', \`)Q\v l"\ormr, wo\"\'\') "\“\f'\€ GLQ/\Q€"\SQ» , ‘j°\& K"°W/

Bwni¢ F><>si+i'o/\ +%r‘ow%hou+ ~Hqi$ whole @a,s€_ )`5 JAQ+ 7%55
w&$ a con§cnsual a<;+, and :’Ve_ +0[@[ h,`,,/, 'LGC;/ ,“A }+§g

OL COr\§€n$L/\Q,\ QO_+, §QL,L}Q %Q\`r\§_ -I~C> m\/<L "'O Commur)¢!Q&t/Q
~H/)CH' 7Lz5 ~H*)e J`ur:) I+ wou\o\ -€,i‘r¥\€v be %mu`§h 1'1€$ S+Q+<m€n{~
l "t'® `H')Q Fv\(€& o»o_ lool<\`m?y +hem

. _ 136 he war>+s J%>P"€$€”* 7%@/‘

PO§`_S`I'!>/€, way 7Lb dO "\‘/L /‘5 %h/D

l/’l eouf/' ,' is 7%4:)/' [’Or/’€O)L B€m/C 7.
`|`HE DEFEN DANT : yes S/`-¢ .

“VHF_ COue-r re++j MH wha+ has 710/01
you ?_

'me DEFENQAMT; yes s/`/a . (F<'~.R. \/0\ s’:/<,a>,/¢,¢))

" g€hf)"€ , 1`5 _H’)LZ'}"/J

139 PHANr-: S'T‘:LL.E;s ~

_:DCLP;\O“\Q/ 3+\`\€5 -HS~J-/`Fied bn Cm$$ €)@mm@#d'vj
96 1@2[(6005? Q,. S F<ar as +hQ, meaio&\ r\@®,.d&/HOU/Ue_
+€§l-__i£ied +here‘$'m)+hir\%_ in 441€,~@ ,'nd,~Q/+{hé_ lnw ®Ej
`m)\£r\`e§ are<fc`>mo\ on ‘1}/!91. Qome/<,.a P¢Op/es 15 #,@J/ a@n@@¢?

(-\° Q owre¢\_' "Yy`\£r~e,`$ (\b‘\-h\\f\%, \/|TS)\S/C

C\>¢ G\<o.»:\ .Qnd -H'»o&‘_$ & mu\+ip|& a®@ QGQK<>J¢ 4
wwc,\n §§ pr€§>@\red in a WO~PQ` /<\" €mm¢`noe\'»`@n ?

P\. ye$ UZQ \/0!$? .'/02,/03)

Q`.Qcmd l 09 QO\M`S€,, +“l/\C emm\`ncd~l`on, +he p'@/l/I`C/ @(QW"'n&h/°h
C>“C `m$~ peo‘>|€, m\/QCL\S 410 +he heal#qa€tre PVOFQSS"OM\
€V€-Y`:§%""’WB» fS V)Orm\ ?

W~ 5[€5 (f&.€. Uo\. Z’.)w)

®"WA cls Far 25 an

war 9035»‘@0\ ev-f<!m€@ am bm”'”é\
1406 ~PQQ‘¢ `H/UA `TY\S. §§eop¥e. Ccm Sid€r~S {4~'40 196 v£<>r€\`b\&($€@
§ucv\ 23 OQ~J exaan 09 m' /
' medical F€

®r` _ ll ,~
¥ PO"+ SU,')}SOM~\\/E, ®J:)\L};§r` QO,,)Q+JY:::S` +'1/;+&
:`/h;::a§ 50¢@5|€? irH~€'”CO€/U'SC/ wm wm &dm,`+ 4_0 me
‘ f\c:m€ .

H, _Ther€. §§ no Phj$\`€a.\

ewdencsz 041 +m+, no.

®1 903 (Q\O»C£, +V\CL-¥ +h€r€_ (\,®u,\(§ (Qossib\:§ be thjl@~\
:\:;S;_QMC; IV}` +V)€, m€d(C(L\ P€,FOFJ\~S 45 CO(`V`Q':)QMAHL
c 5 Q_ 13 313'¥\¢3 /JJ/)c{+ 5}’)€ was ~//12€ Ul`C;Hn/)

§> Fc>fz:e m_+¢rc@(,wsef 714/wa ~an+ is m+ \vpr€$en+

m `…€ m€d'@t| '“€PC>F%§ ,m). (/2,2.001.5’:110,~)>

/@qu po|\`QQ, @€P¢lf‘i*m€l/\JF.
(EP Ub\§§:)m) He +001< +w© SUXLb$ WC*"‘O’Y\ qF/Q€\\CW“
cheek Jro Qc)'mp€mq DI\)H F€QQ)\)€\"@\

Q”om &LL€:}QG!\ rupe/g ('<QJQ, 420).3>;1[3’)

~3'.

V\P`\'S~\- L,,)r)H z v

1415 § Mn\< <&<»S+\¥\‘Qd +w>»+ am is C\ “F€C"""%“".

`“Di € TQ><&$ Depar+m€r\& @-P (i>g\b\\`Q SCFF»`:_U Qmma
`Lubom-wn:>. (E,)Q.\)o\.z;: \1\) She +es+\`€\`€§» +m+ SHQ
A”`CQ.\`Q\)QQ\ JYJr\Q r\O\\PQ J<\`\~ \cVOm &Qr*\\o\a\`no\n~\v ; `H/l€_ SM)’S
£me clppe.l\cm+, CLF)O\ c\ QOf\Aom ~ L)O\r\\@\n +uw\ec\ Ou+

+O be umwa\a+ed +<> +%Q Cc\se. ('R.Q_o“\..z?:ms~) f-\

Df\ +he ua@m<m Sm€ar amd cma\ amem slmu… (`Q,Q,V»/,s:m€)
`Fw\rv\er~ +es*vs neveo\\ H/\oc\~ +h€ 5)@'”€'*\ +€S+€O‘ ‘*)‘L~‘>
COHS¢`S+€)®+ vo\`+k 6; ml`)<+urc <)Q/Dm €L[)/Qe/lw'»+,f/he gngla/'r)anf;
CU/)Ol an <,m/C/)own~ inOI/'u,`@l¢,@l ,(Q,Q,L)D|,Y 513)) de

S\r\€, -MY~H\€Y~ i§ asked b:) FrbSQQq-H`<m’.

Qn-:\::\L &>©u cL\`O\ m>+ reafer &. D'UF) Prma"`le O’n

%ihd mp\e, from her 1901th swan O+he’”
P€’IBO~ +c> mm 01 compw~/Sm , Qorr»ec%?

F\. l\)@, wa @L\‘c\ no+, (/2.)?.¢))\,€;: /3<;1)

C/~o$§ * €><ch"nCL+/`Or)

@¢ QV‘WC\ how 1003 would ~H/)€ OIUF} 09 613/9er
G@H FVM:HOn be ago/c +<> be r€e@ue»»@o canal +es%<>@\

'/L;;Dm__\_g>u m wcrom WS. Peo)ole.
» :)Y>‘CO~UK on ann S+{\\ +rj +€) Cf€\/‘Q\ é’~ 9a
pm£-\`\Q \'~Um` )' " O(D
<Q@VZ,UG|.L;,’I.°>‘~); HUQ' days a:§)t€r S€>(UQ" 'H+EFMCJ

FR€/ Q\( *”Q°F §><cw\ \`m+»'on

®‘ 30 +\O\`& wl€r)o»©n pfbna!`l€.,¢`; ~an-}- 0€@@53&""@
5§;€: ,0»~ (\,@%\@\ \`&~QLSO be game &Lher +;jPQ*
I`D

lay CcL\ \»W\<:Lwdal `7.
4.

P\.:E~\- sound m gap Q@\,\S',,w+ +he UQS,=U,
\/au{_\_ mack EJF€OJCS dbu©f\ S|<\`m C€..\\S YY\\AQl/\ mgr€

§LWQ'<\ +hcm 3+ does S\Orem calls . S‘Q po+€f’+"`@\l
c+ com d be sum cells . \mor¢ /,‘;<Q/

H' lymasz
CCLYY\Q <Q@m SPFQY>”\ [E.iQ. ()ol. 83!3§)
. /p\€.Q,POSS - €XCLm'i-Ua;{~[()rq
§‘h:nymam HC)L,\ CCU’)`+ SCLU »01$\/’1 Cm:) CP~""’L@?HJ
\ ` `H’)€ SP€W'\ Qel\ fincham qQ/om an unknown

, Q&m€/ 40 106 in 7"/’)€ UQ ink\ ar€&
O@ \{WS. PC;D/)/@/ C@h you y 3

H‘ ND[:C@V`H` .

®- (-\nd 60 n<>\~\m`n Pn>m ‘H’)GL+ +€SH/Jj +f[/§

b`OV\€/\ +i/¥H~ was p ace 7b1/2ch ?. \')Wv l<n¢w

hL w@/:‘> +%er@ 2 ‘ _

F)F,'~tjeah ,)u$¥ H/)&+ l‘~/“ MS P“>b@~b/j w"u"n
waive citeng

CQ. :C:+ mv@wr mac been am hw?.

Av. Corw;@;}q ("Z-E. w|. 8’§ l§’é)_)

gamm@r 0\= THE ARGamen+
.,¢,OJ\ V\`\S \C{(~s+ `I'SSQQ, A\gloe\&)'\'\‘ O\F \A€.S ’H/U"{“ `Hl€. €/l/l"CLO./l€£
Qr~c)o\u.c:@_ OQr +\r\e %u\`\+/irmc>o,<¢r\€i P Ol"`& UOO@ '\”\SWQ{Z"Q"@”/L
+O $\APFO¢~’¢ %e, \/QF~@L€Q,%- cwa @w’l+j ‘ pre.llcm+ reaches
Q`ono_ms(@». 10 \9@~+ b\i> `Hq€ [ac_l< 041 med»)`c_a) Qu/'oLch!;
SUPP°"'*"`“<§ `H/d€ Clm-`me. O)’z ed. 'TF\€_ +€5!“/`»/)/)®”$ fF/Om
~H/\€, W\Qoh`ccd Q)C[D€r+ SV)Q»OS H/)@)”€’S 140 SI`SV\ 013 H\€
OLHQSQQ\ Q,r~lme and m MQ+,QQQO.»<{,‘H» w ~Hm+ sowa
Q)€§)€h’r. `}“h€_r€. MQ, am Lm§den)s-i€)'€<\ DMF\ H’)Q+ ‘JO"*S
pmp‘u@\ 1CO\U\0\ wi%{m ~Une r\OLP€_ l<\"v 532erqu gm
OOV)/\P|O~M\Qn‘¥` @)SQ, OLQQ..QM\`QB` +€> +1/1€, medical €)(PQP+'/
Jf'h€j ©MA FC><vw\c\ wH-h{f\ +he rupe l<\`+ wild mma b€€l’)
v(`¢2.%»\`(>\@161\ d&p©$\"\`£ H"Om up 113 -/C/"\/Q, 521ng aidq "'ZT’)@’€¢\OV€,
+\/\e €\)LOLU\QL pmdu@\o\ Q@u\cl Qo\.$i~ a` Sm({zm> o{la
doub¥ CU/\d ~H’)@r”@f;`)r€ »`5 fm%h@¢)“m'ew+,

><Q"\ \”\`\5 SE.QQ>V\Q\ OLDC{ +hi-rp\ mgth ,£3( €H(m de
`{'m*' 4/}’)€. 4`/1”\'0~\ Cc)uf)§~€\ was fn€w£ff@£)'\/QPF;J\ _7;1/@`) 3
b€,CQu/\$Q \f\€ \Qa\`\€d -¥0 (>rz>\)\‘<lg `O\ \@rz>\@@» Jf¢,'@\ §}FCGL<’jj-

“Th€ Qou\'/>S~Q\ adv\`$ecl H\Q appellan+ @~(1 `Vf\€ Cl@\[€h$€.
0@ QO¢\$U)SULQ\ sex and wm ,q,@P€//W,+ ,L;WL he would
mae +c> ~4€3+¢“@ im 1@¢0»»\+ 09 +M; jury ip 711/,@+
de@m<»_ w +r> be prese,h+e@\. 'The SP@+L \@\'1€@1 €<»,vr€'/V"“'

FY)OH°"‘ 40 P"€§@/"‘+ €XMH€OMS O-F`f€")$€§ d)“)d 1440 oler
§c>un§€\ §~Hll ac\d¢`$€<>l \l/wz ¢}fQ//M% -/»0 _/¢z_/;c fha

l/O¢`+ne$$ $Mrd /(V;Ou_)¢`/\B. »//l/)Q__+ ,`./- would 0/9€/) ~/¢\Q doow
‘FOr\ ~H/\e, adm¢'$§l'®r\ O»@ `H’\€ €_5€'\'1’231>’\€0\13 0‘@‘@5’\5@5 1 `_'_[;l€ COuW\"
even ,Dr\ r€Q@rd &c\mcm`shes C@umse_\ %Q+~h¢’.s Uo$$”
examm@+\`@n 0\¢'~€\ §r€ér€§ w:>H-r\e§s 'elfg+ed F€SPO‘”?SQS
44’\¢1* GF€VW€O\ `P\'\€/ dOOf` -l-c> =e><~)-rzm€®m$ o~F-Fen£€$. “TFLQ)/eé¢\e,,
-,\/H`LL\ COUWS€I §)’)ould hague H/\€. /(/dou)le@\%k. +O KV)Q\J `/'¢l¢+_

H/\€_`Qil'(l+ecf' €X&m)'nq.{~)`m Cc>L/\p|€d <,Oc`+P/l dQF€Y’ClSM"L
+e$¥'mon§j wOw-\c\ opQ//\ we d®¢ +z> ++\.Q e>c%ame¢»¢c$`
Oq%n,»ses md bow 1@/ @Or)$v;/fu+€ m€?@%’@e#,¢e_/;@$§ Ohh¢$\i”v+-

OOMSQ\ &\$0 uses imQ@€€QH\JQ, qL`Or~ Jrh€ Ir\o\b¢'h`%j +?)
C®\NOMQ+ <>r\ Y\Q)JQ, ~H/\€ unmch =O¥UH voi%~`/\ +Vl@
_QO““P\O~`\»"\M+§ mix \<\`+ +.Qsl,@ +@ \‘Q\em+r¢@:) ~H/\<L
\m\»`uic\qa\. “_n\& +Q§,Jn"m_ Oqe HAQ+ gum VQCL;_»>
mmr€»m-Of\+ +r> +|f\€, Q&$Q, and 44/1€, chQJ< evade/a
50 QCLU»S~€d ~H/>€ \LV‘)'@.\ éoumSe) 40 be /`r)€>#`€(l¥»)'L/Q.

l____$§_@;i
`THE E\/IDE)\)QE :r;§ :LMSLAFP:LQJ;\JT "1'0 gupp@Q-\»
”sz Qc>z\)mz:z;c~rlor\) OF 961(-:1 Qauf\‘lz-zo S€)<unL HSSHULT

kp\>x@\\<m¥ ¢<r~g>v asae¢+s +m*r ~H/)e. emmng 15
`\v\w%¢¥fci'@/\+ +O suppm\r we Q'~d;j/LSS 041 <g;w*+§
D¥~ Q.<:)mu@+<d S€><a/LOA asswl+.' es+/`m<>m 7%”’)
5€\)@»/¢1 041 Hw< 3+¢1+<';8 wl`+r\€$& CLS»”€Q MQQF %€na,
wm no P*\ 3\@\ w med.@\ @U»‘@Lw¢@ +O‘Ml
Su<:)cje$lr +1/\€ H'rd,`né 09 013@ W+€d §@Xu@,/ cumul+.

\;ow\~$ f
.-\`\'\Q. +€S’\"\`~\Qr\a 545- DC\P\/~,O,nq 5'\~\'\\€3 /, \,Ol'\S~l/\ %u€§‘/fé>f!<-C’
bLj d€f€nS€. &Hofnej , \<)P\`~TB§ +O \l'%\’)i` `H'M'}“ 71///\?'~‘”€
was no PP\§/j$»‘<w~\ nov medl`@\ in`w~`@§ +%a+ SU, e$*`a
Scwa\ assw.?+ cocawe.d. [Q.)z. z,z,/.Y : /'@z,/O@,/OS`/ /@'
"TF\~U~¢S no meddcol vepcr“\z$ eden dOC',c,w/)€H‘¢Qd

\|/hq‘\» §hw;§ an grava +DM @@/)))¢Ql/`cw)+cw+g gen€k\ra.
[Q.Q. Uo\.§§_ 1 ;|@,m:))

Tv\<, 4-@5>¢{.~\0~ ma l<m+§ Lmla ,wm works as -
a"" 466?\0\`+1`00 UJF +h€ /T€)la.§ De/inr*)-m€’?+ 0# pub/ff
SQ£Q+:} who J&S+Q,d ~M\<’ fa!o€ l<¢+ Vor Q/UF} a/o/)j,

umw appelmr)+.,re.\)@l +V\q+ ~Pv\€f€, was a J/A¢m{
D\\Nq S[D€C°,£men -H/Dm gm ban /O/)ou)r) p~€ré’D»/) F€®\;QY@QQ

@\OW\ \H”)€ @O”Y)PliM'/~'$ OO,Z{AQ' O…d Mql Smea/~
§l.'@re_ (/2.0.0@1.;):13))

MO O`H’l€f q;rz;-P{|Q_ w&_§ PQ_Q\`Q,UQCl 113 kg'/- Qjcu"/l$+
`/’h€ \,mlénowr) OfU/‘} S`FQCI`me/q .[Q,Q.UOI,Y,'/B<Q)
I<m§;% Lj/,/( Q/§O !e§vL/H’m' %%»Q¢L D/UH /"1 v‘¢w Hrm

S`@'“€W\ GOQ\<X P€S\'O\Q i"\ +L\'€ UC( v\"'WGL\ UO“U\’\* L»f}@‘/'O
¢\\)@. Clajs and +hcd- +M unknown pm,£,'/e umw more

P*”O[%’°’Z +v be 5/3/’€/1/).¢'(£-/2,*£/9£;§/.'/3$¢, /35`/

S'THMDHF<D c>P lZE\/Ic~:<m

-An ek \e. 0\\*3 SU$“C"QYQ.*“QJ remit ;M:?a\/QOG:;;:
'O<>’€ <Ur' ®“ *§Q ‘QV"‘*”M `Y` lig:>:§€d©m +m+ ewde
+0 +\/\€ \/e»»oh`©+ OL{/wo\ devlekmma%, pmm Q p&+lbm,
and reasonable m@e renQ€S €r€ , _{ wa
\`j\)w:> QOMLC\ have Qggmd 44/\€ QQQ\,LSSQC{ gu¢ +j

am +he, elem€r)+g ©+`~ ag§j`mua+€d S§xual Qm/+ 1990/d
Cl r\@a$@r\@&,/Q dou@. 333 \LO\CKSGM \). U»r$jm`@\,¢/»<,LB U‘3.30'7,

'zlq, q<) KS_Q+t zr)?//. Q,/ L,ed,zd fw (/9’/‘7)
<Qr\ cl€+erm\’m’@ w¥\e%e»'

+DQO*’\\/"O+z%€ C<)w~+ mus+ €>fam:n& +4/)<+@+&|1`

915 M”\€ C\"PQ;LmS-}anc£$. D€r\+or\ \/. S+u+;; 9//,..5»£13.2@(/
388,/ 339"‘?0 (j_€X. Cn`m , APP /995")

n &UldChQQ \S hoi* SLL-Q€:`Q,`erl+ L,mGl.€r” 7‘4/)¢`5 S'Ifl.n@hr€| fm
§QW» Q»`»~Qums‘vomce$:

') +h€ *”€CC°>YU C©m+@\)`r\§ no eul`@l:mc@ Pmb@+"l£ O`aa`n
~Ql€mer)+» C>~,C +he 0#@~5€,,» ,,

Z)+he. r`moro\ C@n~+cu'n$ m€l’€ r(moC\:`Cc/H'h O‘A €U"CLMQ€
)Orz>bQ+\‘U@_ 0£ an el€m~€n+ OF H”)€ OWCFCHS€,

3) ~Fh€ €Ul`d_QnQ€ Q.on&l(/{§|`Uqu ;.'§~}q_’$hes’»: (’@/@HQSN"QMQ

doub)'

   

L/) “H’T€ CLQ+S CRH€@QO\ 010 HO+ (B@n§+v`vlu)l€. M»Q_ er`m,`ra]
Ow@vQ:¢/)Se (LI/lcw eOI

j ' BPC)LOQ 31 §Sh;z~ f 331 5100. 3d \%5_/5`,73

(_l/:YQS, F}Pp ~€Q§+/m©) él@/<Q. f no pQJ`_>(QiJ}/n

§b\bcé::\g ’:L H) 4110 H)ax@o\ +hcd~ +he eul'del/)Q£ is V?.QJ\“
'e”‘ W"OU»*“ +4'\\5~ 846deer , %Q Qe)//)Ul`CH"b/’)

Hjl_l:¢:: ge r€/U€r$€.d W cm Q<‘,Zu/'HQ/ €/1+€@04 566
» 3 \}. Fc)m'd Ll$"”)u \ ‘ ’ :
w .3, 31, »L!( , )Oz S.C+. 2941 ,.

551 301 (@S`o\ [l‘?@) w ll

qa

”Disws§ic>n
(A\>\>Q\\cm*v assev+§ €\~f/\oL+ +he e.\) <Ck&nQL §0@5&1+<04
Q&+ab\(S-AQS O\`P€&§Qmab\a OLO\M>+~ (,W€ "l@f)h'mo_nj
09 mg 99 7%¢; S+€L+€-fé wi+nes<s€$ &€)ree 'H/\cu»
+h€ ph\\jsi<u\ and medi`€a( €UCCUUWQQ is ,°nQons)`sM/p¢
O'” doesr)‘+ S…Pp<`)r`+ +4/1< O\C.+ 0€` mpc F}lso cmaf

mO§f\` §i%/hi-@[Q@m_\_):j 1 `H/,e [Qb +€.Q)”)"U`?%`O/`) chr`~ HQQ

i(£::::i::ep@~»m@+ @P @§)¢'Q SQ&@ ,/(m‘g+~j /\,",\K/
_H/)€ m ed OE’\ bLVllCVlOw/n \DNH Sp€.Ql`me¢/; wIH/lr/\
Q)(P€H' I;O\`+ne\,k 010 di®mP/CU m&m+ CU’\({‘ /lO{~Di/?€ @f" 7%€
an Q/m& H`r:)$:s pu+ m 59 +z».< 5+@,4@ a@glcl fmha
SPeQim€I/` `… . jammi es+/mcd& wham Q)+l/)€r~ D/\)A

/, € Uh\CV)O\/on Or~ 7aer i/he Q/@ZD€//a/#,
1095 dep@§¢+ec/. "lb€, Or\\ aoanuslo/w wai’>c+m@&
’\D"HM'/\ lC\. jB/UC (5`) d@§ `Qné)({. "77`1€ FFPS€J“C€ Ov@
m w¢<m@@n DIUH m 1'%5€14 arm+~e§ CL./*€qSO/)Qb’€
dowd and +V\`€ 1936 J%a+ 1`+~@0€»/)+ bm+es+€d +©
§Oc‘-A,;Ey `[>;qg QQ$@ /_ prejudice -|?he &ppe/lQ/I+. TH€r@qForQ,
+NS CQ$Q Shw\c\ b€ r€rmmd€@l 'OOLQ!< 1'0%€
Gow+ Fr)/~ a new %r/Q!.

IO»

‘ISSU€, *”‘Z €*5

COLM\§€L E§)\) berge/z ::\\)EFFEC\.m/é HSSZSWNCE
BB/ FV-}I;;/\)G 76 ‘PQOUJ;D€ H PQGPER /)E,:F?L §7%77‘559

900 331 FF):V_LI/\)é§ /)'© :r\)u/;STI&HTE wee F)Lr£/m/)’m/@
DI\%\ .

j Q\\Om+ oL§ser+S +%Q+ h¢`S +1~."@,\ Oocms`e.)
wm§p<?ig\€:(¥€@+r$:>(:©r puL/SLL¢`n 61.4¥`\"&/\ 5+@“}`€3‘3 "/?
which cnde +h@ pm§€ +~/'@~ jo c»%k QF@`,_@¢M@
09 Q>C+mh€m c>#€ehs€;», am\ SOWQ wage/l y%u/ed
WLO iV\O@S¥¢§cL+eo//) and have +1/»& “LQ/Q;cm©am~ Dr\];f)

+€5{~€0\ &nd Qompar€d Cl\<jau`n$§» ~H\€ COmP"@-"VW?'LS
Shkmen-,L,

FHCT§ :

` @V, ¢r€mw 1@, 2914 l q h@w\`n\ UQOL.§ held
… which we 5+@+¢ ~Pi`\@ a N)HQQ oP:)r/H€h+ *O
use e><+mmw; (>/QQm-e§ Q.@Q@rdm. +o we #O¢ Q“a
+he ”Q>@s Q\»»\e§ ma wth DW uo.‘.»@u)»e
©VI>Q€€C[I`/]%S OU`+S\`CL°~ "/V\$L PF€§QI\Q.Q, O'p `/’h€ \).LU' ’
wa/)S€l ¢<>» deQndam+ /ma)cas a verbal cj€€+/m 1‘©

`H’\Q admission bia ~H’LQ uS\`m G~P … Q><!~l'élm€@u$
@>#-¢`engeg . (@;@z‘UOm:sz¢)> /lf\e Cow+ mm <‘»M\S@l

®§)@QH@»/\ mo+.‘nr\ w \`+J/\ +wz I’\OHW)

`H/\¢H' »U*\Q CU>OF `ISY\`+ @‘zen€_d amd eden OdU/K€S
@OLU)SQ| +C; S+ajj CLMQ </€?>m `/W€%. [E.Q.Uo\.'?,’Z/o)

/DW»/% -Pm ka+,`mom 041 ibpth SH\Q& q(r];,\

Qm$‘@@“m@t+»m b Mr. S%m<>| ,.Gomsel el,,'Q¢QA
[\€5®"]3€$` `M'W;+ @p€i'\€_{\;) ~H'\Q_ amp ._F'Gr\ US@_ C¢p"/_he
€)<~meous O%‘+);nses ,(`Q.Q` uo\.gz)zo) 'Dr(%ler ++1£

       

o_¢- v..'_¢_i;/

'4‘@$¥*"\‘>'\ 0 ` Q 3 `Ie;z md w+@\`&m Wl€
@\"€'5€"®- § +{:e©:?r~… , +Mjr;: Q@W\~ &duise$ CLJL§’€nSQ
@QBUUSQ_\ ~H/\€c\~' <Q§Q\`XQ;\ F€’S 05€5 <pl’z“>m DO?FM
SH\€S VYKL \/\Cu)€, @Pene@ Q dC)O/`.‘ CIZ.Q,UOLK°,B‘Y,HO)

fD\,\H/\% S\`bc bar Cbue$iw`m\\'r\a 01& &pp€ll_a/n+~

56 *M @@w+, @Uhg@, MQ\ wmr+@ Mhe

S\W>m%l? admst appeIh/hl 40 %ash-@ on h¢`§ Own
be$ul# E.rz\z>:u@z<,)w,)

'@…"O‘”`I @"r`* @M>Q\<>w+ \,Qr\\ @q>@n wa won +<>
`}`h€ ‘QX'H’UM€@M_§ @_PR/,\.

(M~ U“" 37 '° '?>'/ w) "?R@"un )<nj>:'q'%`r>r;; OOWM'M"°L'
nwa" +€S"LQC" [’3-‘?-0<»1~?..‘/3<;2) ' - `*M‘S

72.,

STQNDHKD 0+: 12€1)2@3

_er greququ ©1@~ review ~For §n'e»@€eQH\)Q QSSI`&'\)‘@/)QQ
09 Q<>Lm${\ is SQ+M,»+l/q in S+njol<|c<//p( u. tmwhmg+m /
’~Mé» u=%. leb$?,)©v#§.€+¢;w§a 30 L.®'.zd &,/)¢ 09me
“E>w@ U. 31¢@@;1¥) am 3d §013 (W.&,…,fo,lo@g)

"[?> {DFHU<L\`\ CLHQ€HQ/H- muS+ <H`rs'v’- Shoc,o %ML h¢B
COLUW S€\`S P€ w@e\~manqg, was O\@€,‘

Q|`€H+, §+Pl`Q/C /Q/zy‘ L/'(Q@ /
U'§. q+ <@<z'v, zoL/» S.Q+, Q+ RO<QLP; E>me ; '7'7 S.Lo.:-z@)a+€¢%.
ép€Qi‘FiCcL\

\é iga/ij appe/Iw,+ m_u.§)‘~ prove ,. 33 @L
P"@Pf>r\damn`¢e @+1 we quow)ce,,J/m+ hr’§' G@cwsel')
*":P"€YMN m pen be low +m 0@~<@‘0< Q+Mm¢

0 P'"°‘Q?SS’@“C\\ m>¢~ms',' B@n@,rms;w.zd Q,L§:z?>
v?mja;\r)QX?['/d)/) QPFQHM+ mus+ Sh<)w Ma% %I/)/'S d<Y/Q,'@,/-

WQ£ ICP“QJUOU`Q€| h`§de<£€/UQ ’* ’
_ c ¢ ,_ m€Qm 0¢¢\€~7¢
m …L»\S* 6*\@ q MY+, LQ+

w 0g Y\CCLS<>UQL>IQ pmba;bi{l¢"

V` hi$@©un§e/S U|"lp/”D~)QLS“S!`GVYL] UVW`S .,l/H~c rE<SL,bH-
QF- \qu@ /sz>c`eed¢‘n, @m,\d VLL`LUQ, ‘O€€A/d/}QF`Q»@WL, 13
(<`LUC>HH§ M\&hel\\\/\ S+@LQ (p$` J;w- 301 <Q#O,Loqa (?§)<.
fir/m Qg>. 'ZOO>~) ”Tn@ Q 53£\\<~»+ mm+ sh@w +hq+
`Hwe¢~e i§ a hea.§cy~c¢&>le pm `

blh`#j ++)a+,qb$€m¢ HLN.'WS
+ha Fq

né_ OL»ULL del UQr$Ci»/,‘Q{ pmce§§ ~MQJ~
):)€ l”€ //'€`0/ Orl d§ ]/wcL/a'r)' gm

v umw
SM/%<@@H@%,/ .SC+QMO<O§/»`

€` `PF`|Q/ C‘Q]H/\O_l_
&`)u$+ (f`€§ul+.

730

"D`u‘,u$§iom

an&&\ €\‘Qd_€d C>V\ OPQM~QC§ ‘~\/Vl€ dDOf` \+O €U|MQQ`.
+*m~e¢ §§ ms &\e@n+ up Hw lm'P@&@h W*€V"L bj we
`SJY®L’K Cv\c\ CLO\Ym. cle@,t/b/p+"§ Cr”€d{b/`/f"+@ w'M'\
\3\::“?§ ' Q.)`UU\ \H\Jz, inherer\#\- ppg\')uo\(@'@\ ncdur\@
§ l :Tl:n £¢WM @@Femes cw) jim 7%@+ #w/,§

PP\ b `+ 5 kGL)>@Q%S,€. resie;;i climas+ erl%¢/r:/ZC bn 1113
@'A@@l*b’ l""§. +1’\€ CQ`>LL\O\ mg been f\é> V`C » hale

+N`Ol\ 3+%1€% H>,» QHQ@MM¢ ;< emma so Q//</+
and @P€n 714/16 dOO,~ 473 m Sc"m[l»"@» Q)<%/wzews
S?§. 561 Q¢ber+goqu, §+H+¢ 1377 5.£,<). 3d 4’75:<¢$"%’

g(v' [T€)g Cm'm, 4@0.100(¢)/'@ 150 goc`l\/`cz/Y)B U. SZ@J€ (D(@;Z S,LD' 2017
E’>“H, 5% (T.~Q,/, Qr,‘m,QW . l¢)x/;>>j (71,,~§. ;5 l faular-

l
~Fi’"u~€ wm 615 hara .4`4’\@ QL@\QMSQ SM%€jj uM/§:jéamo@
Qn‘he"€\d ©V\ `)N C\€FCV\C(Q)"H~§ CV?:€)I"!Q!`I!¥j \/€/‘5€5 JM
emplq.'ham+’$ Crecl/é,~),’+g, Q/QQn//»S` HLQ doo,,\ wo<£mw//,Q§
%€OLQC€V)SQ §+mk&<é final 5€)~\/€3 no urpd$€ ©M%

+@ P'“fju@\"@¢ we d€¢@dan+j Q@,‘/,'@ ¢@
F’YSW in§ 0/€1@/15{_

F`DV` %/"5 ch€ SHO</c/c/ be r€mqn@(QO/} IOQQ/<
+v.| +he C@U¢»,L j%.~ Q new W,~'Q/;,

l 741

C/CF\QLU 31@\;) two PU§&Q

\)5\`\€(`€ -Q)FQ,] p(`CYY\\`SQ\S Q£Dn$’,der`€d /`…,Q HPP€//Cm+
"€%ULQS\-S +"\)1 Cmur+ +0 ve\)er&& ~)M Q®f\u\’<l+ibm
®J€~ … Q§>p\»;\\an+ am +ha basis 09 vU/uz €m)r$
S‘v@€re@l exan mma/nd H\Q US€ 100>”,6\.)'\'@) %`a.(.

sal
,,.

/Q€SPQ&LQQ[)/j Su }>m/#€d)
(/;F)enm’-Q A-h§~’©’v ?ZQ .

B€V\m"€ hr)S/Or) 'JV.
AFF€I[QM-,Prz) 5a
'VDC:¥ M>. I‘W!Jos`g
Mcv~l< w. 54+)@3 why
?>OK@G FW) 35/%
B€Qamz)/)?L ,Tc>@;
’7’7’705`

ge QT;LFJ;CFWS OF &zuloe=

’W\\`z §§ +c> Qer+f&$ %.OL-\~ 61 +_me and C®\‘fr"e.&l-
Q,c>©v§ h€x`e ana wa §Qweo\ mbm/1 )<e\\ej Cnsd@,
.QO&U\S~€.\ 1£`(>¢ `H’\Q S‘\Q-}€, ®‘F`_ 'T'€><CL$ /CH* 7£’/’)€./€)0(1),'@
@wa-j Di`$-+w`©+ PerOr)/\\KJ '5 @~)D'H`Q€_ ,(00) f‘/lmh S}F@QDL,
”\”Q»<W;<W/ fraqu ,q§zs`oz on +h,‘s m £i*z_ doj

O“O` -§`3:" ZOIS`

@Q/-m`& /\n?bn, fn-
BQmmJEhnw/\ ,'~Yr.
QPper/»L 93 56

I, B@…ce “Zx`@hm§@h ',:Yr. 'rso'j# qu)oo§§,
bemc(r Pre§en+\~é \`/\Gomemnled \`V\ -H/)€ m&/A/< w.
§\-{\€5 U\m'+ 09 {/he '\'€xo§ @€POL/Hn€mL OvL
Qw'mlml ju§+f<la \`1/\ B@:wmon+ ,"_Ems lj@£ferxm

/'/l'€:w/ UCW Cmd d@C/CY/€ U/V)O(€r~ engel '
09 pugqu ~\m+ Mx;::j Y<>/C>jo»`@& SHL+em‘€/%Sp Qf€j
+me Ou/\@( Cor~re<~J-.

§Yecu¥ed cm %\`S'_'§:dd:)) cwa l@__ ;O'S`,

76,

