                               -tCflA OXjfV   £_At»V«s_    HO.   "bCfcC'M'

/RECEIVED \                  PlXT^CV^      A^A/OeV - AjfelW-<+-
                                                                             November 30, 2015
     NOV 3 0 2015                     nA
\in!RDCOURTOFAPPi
\     jtFFREYD.KYLE

                                   (tou^ Tod              fteftei\g\A&-
    TO Tte UojooaWiLe Sa^nc^s of -rite: ^ooeT of A?fctrtLi> *.

Lcx>A ko -f\^i ^oosAc-Uon) bP rfppslUrit'S A>Jk2«B dot. 4o 'W -Cw-A- 4Wv(r

-UC<VV.           (\t>y>AUx.\r UrfVb ^OUcsUA 4© 1\iS Goo/4" v '1U. 4/i*V d^JoC; AvUi
    tW.!"U»5 ft&- 6tUo*Ut4 ^uvi ocifclUi \\eims *tf*-L V be- fc**4 dX t^pe/lftn?-
^Wk eefcr (}n>ov,H ^riWVp «v-tkJt^ s*A>sW4?*l (L^Vfe, -tw\ *rc-S>t>



      ^JU W^UL^ XJU*. ^                                       ^ W. ^: ^ I* *i
-&a\l o4 ZoV*\' TW a'4. 4*. <w^i £r^ C*-\o2> afvo*d$, frtc- ^>Uw £E*©raro«xJ&
Cb WtA e\ E%U -^o sA^ eg^ng4gv4Al» f u>l^L u ^4 04'lw 4a^L

        v*oq          V^\f
     ^e^Wy j&.\*Wi, ^W^ ^iT^l- m- 3>o< fife). iatS^ frnr^l- o«P cAo«-


      Pc^C«!>6>rv^.\vo^ OtKV Oo4 aUcoC^ W Ooioc ~&fCM.i*v &~*-eAy ^>
C^P X\lgoA &gftfcVv . V-olo*^^0- UAo*»e~ l>bou6^ Oi^ 4*<JjaAV\y- (2«X«cWL A;*e
   "ilv^QftV <s^tfcL. *4 *xj^>cMv4u4 -HmA A;k jool A^4^\e/,dk.4w* 4©
    (h. -\u ^>foA«c4: cA -tu e/^>ior4^Vc^ ot «^> MU^*\ at«s4- sAc*!^
   \hA«c_ tee«5 i^AdtMi*SAV& vO «v GnwwyOAV TtfoceeX\^Q AojA^Vv Afcp^N*^
    flWyy> w. Du:>, ft I S-Or. lk&( CK CI )Tgegy WOWo &. 0-S 1. fife^t. lftg (
   £y&rvf Afr««*V **1 ^uory Sdv/LoctL- Ivao\«s* 'W <2&-50>-^X A^oUjW *A «V
   4er«i*l Afresh U o^<U*<**)*)bU_ o*>Ws</?V U SoM>or-kI *w 'fceUtle.
              p\ Iat x/. T&v*<; 3^ </.<>, ^fc (I'M)             '
(8) k voUU- y t>W - ^11**4 ^kis ^Ur u^ AcWlY *J 4Uc4o*L
   bVe^ *^ *>o-\ «»vjMo UU4 U-W^ > \>oWj ipe>^;^ qoes> AW«-/ i)
  4U Wo^jby ^UU. a <U-WL^ Cs Cov^u-UL, for ^w^ic/1 w)U~ ^
  ^^Ut-OAnV v*x^W> 4^\se_ 6V^r^S Aw LH(^ g^r oUJjrS usfKv^ iW.
  ^oAtu.v»s.V sysAc^x -iVo^U^ W>^)ei -irUoo^U pi> 4^olV J>4 1W6oWv/ii^o
  U)Of-T Orf-'^iW ^Ar4C^.s.; .ir l^ ^Vj>fo)»r/^L. Xoj \*.jok\JA s/^4s*w ks
  /^ff<fc\- 'tW arro^-? E<. 'Wt^ \oWy V0<\ SO- 1^. Sgg.


  t/\o4v»A>> f ofA\ PCqo<^$4fr o<- le4W$. A^l A^to£.HAiAV> (t-^orAAC-V' i.;!

  Qj«W^A V»V "p\etA. -CA\y £^'^£.c4^*>^ A^^Uff^. Q£M\&** A-? 1 4.it4-
  T\^t\.*^ i^ oV*-*- ^4~ ft v^»>gA.l wiiV" 30 iinyt o4 t>U^. SUaiky Q' SU(j>
   S^& sO. iL z?>\ 7Mt ^3>>'.                               ,        /
      {to^xilA^^ ft^^eA-l Jill -f0''"^^ ^ov/tie, *v J«a/ L^ie^> £>"T ^tJote^uL.
  ^TAasA «Jt«t -UvU Cbur"\ WS kV^l A^ O^Wl^tu -Cor^l
\^ftsWv0o4<O MUU P.<>. Lftgf \qfesA A^«Al*ij- w)Oo\l d*»K>-




       fCS-W"« V   £oWy*v 0^\<-*orvooi vOV*—   v/J 4-*£* We_   <Lt«L (Oo"v .
  /" <WT*L *4 A^e\W4'> Peooevt 4>r '.
               CASE. LAO *nA-        L^auA fes<wi«A^




 ? fV>pel\^4 W,U*r*i ty <Aar^i L^'c'^cS^S Cokou*,*^
         - C^-ttv(_\ftv%t.y »-\ eiA«Lu*ce-


©) ft ^«vs<&w*kJLL ^fot^loAAv ex»\.4s ~1U*4 t>^4 -Cor £4>oJsaV u/>^ro^&s:^A
      >^o^o^Jc v> L«*Jcu^V J. frtAusJl ^oc.O.S. 3L4/ -KA J- ^jlpr
        UooU a ATUci^s^aI: Art\A ettMV fet. 'protftijfa. LjoaoS^. A^W/oty
       ^>K:£or™AM.oe- u**y No^- EK.>4#wfV A*J I -£,* i**^4*lly o^^C^,


        "tW \aO *^. (2^u«-i.Ac.4 fey ta> cAd*A.4r... Ua_ ovAly A3e^btw«^«.i.
      ?• "fe^^VcY OyA'- vnol^L a^Jla-A^ r^sUuto^l 6v^^-U_

          V^wvU^ l^^i y> CAgfax ^ft"s Si^« 2-i. ^Zi.. Mwv^ cW»*i

                                  3^6
       f„l»_ m% 481 .lis (mO by uxuIlv ^L^es G*A-uoe«-> H*o 1<x>£rA<\
  (UfeWl-feWoc*'   fcls>o   C*>«nViAv^)«, i* \<W«<- fcc/"C«~».V e»V >», lLyWe/-AwT> 4 A-lV ii.TV*vxTJ,
  TWV iWHv ^l <^LL r„L- ^                      \     4gi.ooi- ALU****** o^ U«U>




  v^K- W»W~* eV 1\-«_ '^«v4V SAW ^>c>rS.OAwt {o Vfe-r^o^ A»»J. Tg*. C^^ Jr
  &riWivoi4 ^n>u.AorC (Wt» 31rOH usio oJ*il4-y oT *v leaser .^dula-l. ©VU*nm_
  M-^bs.^' 6 k;«. €JuiUUi. w-# ^>fto©4 „J- tL«. 2»(*v*a. fer Us.* 4\vaJ Av oV- *U- &*&
                                                                                                        >}IK-




  noe



  £xVwC*-2> "b.^Wc^t G©w-'^'> Ic-A^ l*-WwiUwVo/i I- (N^plyW^ S^-.Ax— tuJ« ^«-~

 Avt




5i)                                                Tt»


        it   ***        . »VA«.»     oT UJJ.'Vw ^        i> Cja-*»e/-<VUy   fA»(cjH.L2 A "\ Uo»V «>s- rv liicJC"




  4V i^^ .lk-Jr.1 4^ ^^c> , ^UL4- ^AcrUA> ^L4 y^>
     tor Ur«Lrs. «^ G>n»A A-^i iWsoA y»AKvU»**A ,\> Utota4io/a ©V
• o.scft. <wAs g*w.               raiwv^AL- lji-^ -Vyi Mfi i^* xry",
     jLiA»r«- «A p» £X*<U*~ uLAW IpuwTs.L.Nva^ vs. £fwA for J^os^l oTKu
     W<- Covv>t Xbre a la "\V^ *V»s.W**A «L* wv-eu^-L 4vxVvA« v^Ao Cd^side^vrto^
  'IW \«~«Aw oV \^riS.D^ «v>a^V , "\Lt ,J»v4v»r<_ oV TL*. rfvlU.a«^«i CLf t+~<—
     m*=o \r^v*»«A ii«v*wWv. ft bDelliivvvT *> si^bu. !j>€>S.5^$£Ioa» cVMArTve-S"



5^) ^piiwJc L» edk~*v VA^ 4WpL^ CAsJrc_~&«r A tW<*5. vV




     '1^ \j^Arr*vCv> wvoA b«. Ucx LA (_*A *A uj*s\ *u«l "tW -fcrvvTS £>v

      £AoSe~* uv>*e>   v«*A£vv^e> t^    v~<- Ao^iu. feT *^\-«- (Vtrrd.A\>\4~ • Vv*-t—
      ftt>-t>Al*vvA: u*U (SLdO 4[VsA: Wj VS- br«-£e„>i^rA*v<-a- oT "^vV*—
     S*.V •**»   ©w^- S»( cU~ A-v\i. -^V—1_ £e*«*44U>\i^o Cp^^**" \->ftS vO^j-t'fxueA
     Je* eVwAAr^L. Cft-^se- v-Ai?A_ £-AcoseL <Lis.uv\iCttv.V dT ^TL*. fVaa^cAATQ^,

      ixs«A«S.S«.L -Ctjf 4\>oA ^xLu^ca- V> ie-r^AAvihO e^CL^CA-- A-w i
       V/^ (^A«aWsvA>V«. * "X. A.A ^vK^ry 4V\iJU» ^ v^y ^>ov-jt-*r 4^© -^ej^jfUi-.
  ^RAPfrs Vm ^gLAu>A££ V3B cXS. \SH. X^ %**JL*\Lr fla^Ul' c^^ L>- ^blbC-


 w




                                       So4 8
 ft*l fcA- 3«.U- avv! AvA. Jg-2.3 ©4 IV £©<L. a4r Cv^^aI ?/boJ«/<_
 ©•V Te**>. ^c^^A -Ao as. v/. suUy Y</g «,/. 75V C-2oog^ Awi^-f \A*rr*A-
 lOttS   v»T\ve»^A   <roioifttju. 6«wo<»<_ t^cAuS-e- 1Lt uj^rrrfwv-r u»nr>   (=>»tw~i »^ o^O^s-IirviL.
ioW»v\Av»^ (cA>»it K>e>. bij>c- N-3o/-e>/e>^ a»Ai 'fu. *-&r<L».vi.V &u^r4A» -iu_

ftpp^lWr />A*~As /KwA <V_t ly&o&tfV C£>o{\ A>eT U<W4_ QeJtiA aJ "ft-«_ f\rrc%\--
w«mti*A ,V» 4op1 Tv*r4v. voc^.ot«_ 'tu_ ,*C€«I*jA <^l»v»;,4lci «j sopperf e4"
-1U WATf^t vO«YS rnivLAlUj A.l eUUc^U^ ^ **ciuj|j, oM.4i
 ^nWlU j^ML -^U-V u5cAl Ua<*_ Ate**kl j*bUL ^5^. flwJL^
UU ^A^_ biUA: ^,V, U^;Ja ^u ^jIl!*



                                         S..




^ PI V "^H ?**^-«*- «• "^ <* <w ~.L~I1 a -tU

AO ^^C- OWW 4U W                                 ^,r4 WtJ ^ A^ly,^-{U.(^ y




^tfo»,.^o -rgn, 7i                    I --           -j    [          ""H c L^' f/~7'


                                       fco4:g
                                     lit.
  L^»ftl (ts^Aou (Irsjji. A \\*-c VAv5 Arte. ftVvo^jTS. ftfidv-euHftbU o-o AbbeA)!. CO U&O y/-
fr^w! (\qWV gg& s.io. 2.A. ^1^^2.0. urA G>uA -foi^ ^ 1U UiJ
"tV A«v^ j "tW AteAl«'tk. £r>ur4 l/v.vs 4t-<_ ^ovxv- A«A "'(Ve. A.Ay +0
 1-J ict>6v. eWAAy £n/a\oaT1~ JCL*. l£.<a»vl AAe/w\v^AT\e«r> or i\-«. -VnA dowA"'
 b!)6sV 3 ^>;^4 ftfpA <^I ngioe- kev) fc^/z. CO,

 "WvA C»uA {5\r-^a<-        "1U_ 4v\«A Coo/T Ae-A. or "fL«- UosjA ^poiA^d

 ^Woo^Y 4JU^ ^,4, "lU S,4i^ W o-l TeX*S. Avi lL. 4oV^ C*>"A
 Wov7v^ S^pUT4*AA At**f ee^yesWi Ws.up*A 4o Tg*. 8. ft»»»fr. 3>J$A (J
 S^ letter U ueurl £p*^, wAV. 3^ i^> ,4 *?^ ^ ^rJUk «JX;l -JC.

 4-vAs Jw//\* A\c"Voc^ ^ S>»*j(ttX Mailer <A ^as^. b-ewiiv^a A6>p«e*--1 a,m.<L
  •U 'brtoc^r A^^tel 4*©*** 4«t©**V»* MooT. {\t>bC|L*t iwol>€S. i\-<—
  G«*>A V© GvimA A^ILAlV fcveH\> -^o ^daJ) A-* 1 'tYj* MOTXC^*
  JLl ge.Wi>^ - vU ftU Ask iU 4^ Coo 4 fuA- \o 4m*3e^U.
 1U swppL^UU e^A ap?JLA <^fc* 4o aUUL^^o,;.
   (yPofAs X^ or W 4*> ^er*Xg(4- ^^>^>^v-[ >                                          '   r

   Z. U^oty C«A<T4y -flwiX ^O -W.'«. ^W iH                   ciwy of" fJcH&^bS 2-0(5^
A T^e ^1 Catted: cohsf ^1U a^v^ Av,i to****** rtU>4»»^ Lr



       *   .                tAOSLsoeJ
                                      r-'£>e3U.AegriQyO A^^U^.4 »fo L

^Tl1^ r"^ ** ^G^ f—Vr,T«u* ^,-Py a.I .LcU- uvi~ ^JK ^ Der^y
KaccAcI ^ -tC JUT A.*^ A ivW^U/ ;^ ^ ^^ 2oj^
                                        crj J- ,«                    \>€AiPc^4P*^.V
  G2 "!\Cu* "\U,               Ajrvy A               1jOV> ) L1KWUL ©J 4© (=*-
VveAjf A.   ATSpAl*v>AVS> WcTTlo^ 4toa> ^g-4\e^r>~<a       Am.1 £rtll trw©4c<&^
\S, Vj2-ft- <oy     .




                                                ^Jo^ku. ^\nt$t-*oZ^



                                  Qgfre:&

   X4- L*         £j/4\~«y   fifctbeeefe ~tuA -4rt-t "WsWA-- CVe^V- E>rc &**/•<_
 S«>ppU~«*A»A <Z«*A <vS f^c^W V>urS.u-A: 4e> TcK .?^ ftpp. ft £^£"ti) l)
 ^i ^\ * u^1 ^ ^^ £oc*v4 irwA -W, ty*JkA *4\




                                                    (JL^-U*- ^W'^*\




                                     8 of 8
                     <*»- ^         til":!t*^I S- -WSj

VA<U<^ Oy^oftVv UdcuveY               ^ T&Auo* Ccoi-Vy xTe*AS          \^v

 "ubtte 4o^om>L£ Jobfrg 3GEAt>A te.ki.Oet)'/•'
     6.c(V\iT> .Odl^>. ~*?A:rAl~ iXlLftr-A-c i:Wu.£y 7 bcsWi^A ^ '(U, ikbt>u<~-
Ar-i.U.i r*A ksO^W^ 6\iiC A~*c wtctfcS 4L*. 6^->A 4& AtS-McVk. fe^Av^L.-Ei/
G-- U^vXllft^ Pes tvypAo-Ui ft\Le-Me. y cA £ecori fcr iA^A^A t (fw i

                                         Iv.

Uifr> tv.Pf0^^ >&^ tr- OrrA,^ ^ ^r>c,c^ <A (texcri oo V- ^
JL^ A S«WxW(tC\^ X ^*> OWvAL W ^«A. "oCtv.- -«-^ j^^CrL
jLJLrcW^s T^ ^6Po\.y>4wvfcAr"T ^V Li«c> (K55>UrcA b-^ We/- joAA^. ^ r
jATT OrrowA. UiOvs U t5- co-Coc'.\>* \*
                                                                                   r(
      i^w,, «**. nee**? -^C^l±>.                       v
   zJ) xVk^^AVW- i^Vc vJrruU*. U^ers. aJ aA&W iA- ^ii4r- ^i
  3A X \i\k^cAiki iNVr. vWuW ^'4 4v^> esy^y w^fe ^Ac^. WC>

   4\ W'^l'l OP6- ft*i 0<dV" i^W^evO X s>W^<A V WW- OcrAci^i^
        Co^s^^c^V^ vAA~.£ >^A ^op^^-4 ^^" ^

        ,^jLV><2-Arf d V^>/Xl *V\IKV NfVVCs4\C5,OS. MueiJAfH 4na "VV-^ A^^J-Ati_
        fc~A CjeA.ScyO AU^ cL-^aC^ tfe "^* cWc<^CA ^-LvU. Aa^^



                                     V   H
      tfVr- OrruA^ iocs; ,oo4 evK^ o^W-) c*AV$. 4^^ WAc^j^As1




                              05t-
 ^toAv~\ ~ »<^ W^A WV,A ^ A^-Wk CocS^t b^

CKx'As Aii Arra-PAc^tW-^ fc-A A«\dOv\-Uv rA* UA> A.f t>Ar^ev ^J^wltvAr
&mA (\^fo\M^ek Coov^A( vvA -^ \^| c^^fv^v -* AA'w<A. 4o sWl
Ajjv^A Vj?j-Cv^ uTi^- iV^. fu^p re.Sc-A A-^o-4- A ^A; CouMiA. U^_ waI
 vys^sVfw^*. A ccowsA v/wA vi4l W <U*l W^ b*£<- ccvv^4"4Av*mA




 ntoMf Kei^vbes. Q>,isi\>ee-Ebr ^WLJt r^«%^\ ^^

 > r^L ^c ^ '^ ^ cXAVh M»4A
                                                               \A&*^
    1 r—by aL4jC/ -W»J- -> ^ *"* "^ ^ "4 ~
3.011/ ^ 4r^'£- A>A Carre-cJc c^jpy »t 4fL^ kfcov.-^ AmA 4re.^^o
^AA/0 W ^vswv>>s rX^oAWi 6q.cl^J*A. UiAS -CoroArAei 4o -*L*,
0&*. o4 -tU. AdA0v> Oja>T*/ "^vr^cT ATCc^/oe^ s0. ^6)c
 H*^e( Mycu t^reiA^ n&ibi


                                      ^cL^£*Ac




   "pt \> oRbfc&e-*> -tw4 4u w«*-a*i(i <3?i 4^*. flUAma—±±l
                                                                       -M7
     .,             \     ^               •   Z.C?   .   UrJ    AW.
 ^ -tU.             *-*y ot     —          ••            _
     U       i -ArU_ Wov-*    3oLU-C*l ^.1-UA, va» (\o*U ( Ve^S,




                              3^M
                                                                    £_0, VW£^-




   IVii £or*W<r Dt'beteb -WA 4\^T^eXe*~«LrvA y>Ct>ULe.l
~%QjO St aUlC/A T*rAirJA uik<AlW.tt<,( C.O A^t. AaoVJC «AvLsl AaA
 K)OVr\W<-i CAOS^', tx-^i. C^^GK- Tfftyii CoojVy Cor/ciA »o/aI
rAcAAy W A\loO ^Afi^LA fcjUeSS> TO COUNTS A^vl^Joi
(V5»S.1^4VAvvC<_ ui/\V. L<2-^A ltcik>.<-iCW.




of Cd-CoO^ScA^ t^ aW dOooOC- sAy leA Awl iloiwJbtreA CAajScL ^
(\a! 0RA>€9^ Tt&aM^ LooriK\( £-^orctAt.'«>.0 A TUuAlty 4o p,tfou>
                                                          *r*
 L.6G&L fcCSEfcRuL                                 '
              L >> G^i^Te*                     C       ^ t>€-oi£b


                                          vjo ^^g. -fires, kv-c.
                                 HAH
                                             -3

                                        Tt>sLh




i£   ^ y&> i« (&<? ™ r*>w> ./ffi,*? i
     ^l^V_|^, J> f... -1~. t> A.-.A j^Jkc:
                           .V^»A.Citf
                            c           t

Jtc*.
                                                                                       SSi-i

                                                                                                      A
                                                                                                    e^'


^•V-H:.^^




..:vr,,_..^. ...i;,|^^jt»?Y?M«9renunclir:«s.~^-v<-^^,...•.;.~--^••.;-_;.;,,;^;;. • .,




                          MIRANDA WARNING

   1. »o«h•yetftoftthtto^emlIn^II«lJtlndlwt^1atoanyftatimont»t•D•lld^^at,
       anyitmttmem youmiks maybe usedaialmt youendprobablyWill be used

   2. Any.utcrncrrtyou mate maybe used es evident* afalnst you In court;

   s- ^qSJSh,toh'rea^a,p^ta'^w1^te^^,
                                                                                               <i




   s. ^f^^shttotermlnatettolnte^ewrtanytlmt                                   ^
                            (WAMISNVtlfioilf                                               .   i




                                                                                   7   ~




                                           1   ?   f r,   S^(.A--- tf   j1   Jt

                                                                             >S.
<(wsuu A Tex**                          %x^-xw 4os^ clu^u vV

       dbT/oJ It) &RA.JT /VOl £S3 TO cougTS £la^ LrU^)
     Go«*es .>ioO^ <aWJ£- teuocy f ieWlwT ^) iU «,boUC- sWUL AaI
 A»W\UrcA <-AOS£ aA W\<OV)CS> U^- CoorT \e> VxUo£> <UW 1**4* 4&< C^cLtA"
 Watvl «u^t2*rA» L» AA*. A^ov/e. rjrivw^l mkw/S- a4 it* T^Avas 000,/Ty

tCiooA ^W-«. -CoUoOl^^v
                                       1.
    !lX*Joi«>A«*A" tLctveAtX 4o "^roceA 1>a> Se_ va» 4V-t- Aristae. Ca^uSa. ^1
u)*S Kpy^^ *lf*eiU^ Occ-o-b'a, P^wlk» o4 lv\s "bro«Us4v ftWVwU
W. UKS A5£\,^A 4>y 1U L-At-ff i> 1U 4o3ri b.s4rOA C^u.A 4fUt W^
 l&coU tc_ Co-C£h;*>5<A. bfctW<L*vA($>- Co-Coo^^cX ^44-o.s vs 00T
 CcccyiZei aV "l\A«7 -UtXVAv $wi ^u^. -^ cooJiA. t^A^a (orc^I
   Wfc AA^AtfrAr (!> A &Wu Gfv*W.A 4-aA V\AS A C^sWhAt<^4 £-\aw^
    Xo -pftociKiA. u>"rKvoo"b cooJ^A \AiWvN W .voVu^tA^ajr (wl U\Alv2«*Al^
     A^\<> 4© <L -SO- X^ ftWiS sA OimAcI SUfa e.y. cJ. AH Cjm/J
     3)7 U*J>. VI5\ X4 VAi "flid: " 4U 6r»A^4Aov ciccs. **A* Aofca- o^

   2*\ 1U. C,?^ ^wxA^iiv^aAc \© ^\U»- GowdAA^ ^"^ba- OrffUi SWlZfi.
       A©es> Wo4 ferwi'Atw iwa^U/ "IWA *v AiA< .AaA ti^-Wse. bUU tc
       n^A*- Xer 4W A^co^eA; Lu4 e«4U^ XT Gr^AoTs td Tlte
      (\a.o^e^ jfasSorMUV t^ Hioftr to tAtwce Avs ^^£a>3E^ It-
      '^, '\Lc wCo^VcA Poir CoUA>^<4 Ob» vauvV tc_ Ca^£revv-Vi »o\T-
      u>rrwe.s.s«j^ ftaMsbVv'yw. A/ji uU «Auv4 be- weeof <U-<i

        -Wtoor fc
   3-)^U- V>rxO Vvtr^ ive^ sWtoj i[UA Swu. "$>ri*iWy Oc^wVo^
        U«\«> beaJ A^oi->\ei 4o y^y CArSC X V\Av>«_ /JO f*-*^^. 4p
        ^wvw^A l^s^> . ~\V\As ^ju^.e,> ^w<^ b^c ^roces-^ ^

                                        \43>
       MttftWi' iLt WcAtDHc, Lav\C&jAvi) ©4 >!kuC_ <iocc-S.S (OCT 4^-»_
        \/\Va\v4y "A dtffxutlS 4vcwn -proqniWvUC <A*~«Wit A w>y[Coa_
        A^^S A ^erSD^) Tlfe- fclGrHTTO 'fe.CFE/A* \^\rV\.SO.F 0r U,
        Gcr^A<bvA\©£ ^L^u,^> -ftwb Goy/J^J U 4e~Lrei ' A <L»^S.
        Ndc.4 e^vnrc- 'JkA O.-jAaT Al cxrd^.^s.-UvAC^S- c^oJ^J. i**. QnA

¥J (IV' 5>r*Av»ey 0Wjl>4vo^ ujA> ft^e.^AcA ujoLoA vw t>p^roi/**-l d*J
   I'GCM^ SVOCA- "tbA AvTv^ X V\A**~4<xA 4*? tuv,W4 W~ *)0-e/fcO>
  4A**^ by tViAtl. ©*) 2. oCCA3(oa>S f ty ^Uowve. ,0*; «~«v-0 j£, AtA^Sy a^A
  X Co^-Ueiei 1X_ CU-A- AW^Y.AS.tft4*wc*- ^ro©r»wG£*<Vv>^
   4© VAp oW»\v4 cowMWi.O(<_(A\ovi kfAuje^ Mrr OrrjVow <mA. *£.*
   0) p^vew-vUrH^ ux- u>e«*- bo"K- <ie*A WlW by CA£^* *~~.
  <M %- Or<vtc W -UU \p <Z±>^>A \* £*a\iWfe^M «.ft^-*-
  C*-i>Avj4\te^ 4*, AW <ir\ve<r4^ov^ N X LrV*- «Lrv-e <2V6ry4W* v- »»W ijo^
  4> (\6Ce£5> Ttf£ GDO£t>. X4 W* -Ulel* -IWoojU v-y Aor^c^
£y A4 l U l ^ £Ov)r)7Y Co£ft£LTlo4AL pfcCiUTK £ V\a^c uifvIL- AJdt/~*/oo>
    Pjt>t?Dr^^ Ao AU*-^. e^.i^v^4> #vA «atf Ct^^wcA^ t-iwti-. "our (L«ccri>
   <LA Xi-*aAUy Op^oU^ (b, Your^^of^«y .lv (Vbm-> A^c^f


  -wAofU- W(CS. ot£-Of/eA' ^eWliA vs v^ leopA/iy ci>b los.u>o
  iG^vf uifrvv-esses. »wd cooftrS"toOijlo^oe. i Alio ,brc~W,fcA +u»-Uo~\$.
   (VfC jOor texwo "5>rCS>a*A<-A be "U-»_ £«c>uA"S Prt. £*.<jy£>4eA C>y


^-UA^rA- \s As* tc^Q Ao^;A W 4?ro^ss Awi e:^l "vtoWVrto^ c^ier-
-1U V*rO ^ori>o fr-vV \rt> "^*. TcQA-W f V»*4U, A-wi T^ur W^t^— I^«a*«^ i hA*A>
 (OjVi.frA zh A 1U T«5<^s GywskAAi^ a-I a^V«1- b^^-ot tu.
 ItK*? Co At A Crrw^vPivl      troCaAuvc x

                                  2^3
  latefcE^e l^siAiSEs, coJsi^ee-eb^, X& L*1*A ee>^Vt>lW
   (wo\)^ -^CU tooA -U &&fc-0rc AC^€S5 TO coo CTS> ; LAd LtW^-
   CuA Xor4"U/ fc-q^sVs <W b*c> LvU-wp-y 4o ass»14- cUUvi^r
   4b^ Cloa^ A.-A A^/v5W*- wl\v AU s^«^t ^A^r


     T, ?<k"A*L lUftef, "TDcJ m*. K67843 k^ ^res^Ay
v^cAtcu
jvb -it* lv>v*n>oo<^2. croft i-r &eMfc~ Goo^'by TJrxjte, v^b twl
\> A TcvX- AaA     Lo2s.e;A    Cb?i   Of Tttf rAoTio^ 1     F/^eb
i/0 TH€ ^s.r* bisTflicT touez tA> xJouciA-ee^ *>£ Zo\^ .



   \.l\A> tfleAo^ fr\i>0 IavAcLI AW ArJ|cju>7/J^ %

                                           AAW^Y
      r Dfcbee.    srrrwcr ^wlwg- kt*r.r-




                              3 o43
CHAIR                                                                  xrfgSHSu.                               EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR & GENERAL COUNSEL
  DAVID N. KITNER                                                  &?!*§&                                                       CHRISTINE E. McKEEMAN
VICE CHAIR                                                        IJfl A A »li|                                            DEPUTY DIRECTOR/COUNSEL
  RAMON I.. ECHEVARRIA II                                         V\&? ^J/l                                                        GMXE R,LEY VICKER_S
MEMBERS                                                                 ^"^^                                                      EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT
  ROBERTA. BUCK                   __                               __                                                                  1ACKIEL TRUITT
  jeannec-cEzrcoluns              The Board of Disciplinary Appeals
  DAVID M. GONZALEZ
  wendyADEiEHumphrey                     Appointed by The Supreme Court OF Texas
  ROUND K. JOHNSON
  KATHERINEA. KINSER
  JOHN J. "MIKE" McKETTA III
                                                                                                                                     A
  mike mills                                                 September 23,2015
  DEBORAH PULLUM
  GEORGE A. TAYLOR




   Patrick Heaney
   #1987843
   6535 Cagnon Rd.
   San Antonio, TX 78252
               RE:   Disposition of Appeal Notice
                     Patrick Heaney v. Bradley Gene Urrutia
                     201504147; BODA Case NO. 56585
   Dear Mr. Heaney:

         On September 23, 2015, the Board of Disciplinary Appeals appointed by the Supreme Court of Texas considered your
   appeal from the dismissal of the above grievance by the Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel of the State Barof Texas.
   After reviewing the grievance as filed with the State BarChief Disciplinary Counsel's office and no other information, the
   Board grants the appeal, finding that the grievanceallegesa possibleviolation of the following Texas Disciplinary Rulesof
   Professional Conduct:


   Rules(s) 1.15 (d)

        The Board of Disciplinary Appeals will now return the case to the Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel for
   investigation and a determination whether there is just cause to believe that the attorney has committed professional
   misconduct. The Office of the Chief DisciplinaryCounsel will notify both parties of each step of the process, including
   askingthe attorney to respond to the complaint. For information concerningthe handlingof the case from this point
   forward, please contact the regional Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel in charge of your case.

        Information concerning the disciplinary system, the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, and the Texas
   Rules of Disciplinary Procedure are available at www.texasbar.com. The Board's Internal Procedural Rules are available at
   www.txboda.org.
                                                                                   Very truly yours.


                                                                                      tK^.Uu^ £ /—^-
                                                                                   Christine E. McKeeman
                                                                                   Executive Director & General Counsel



   CEM/jt
   cc:       Bradley Gene Urrutia

             Laura Popps
             State Bar of Texas
             PO Box 13287
             Austin, TX 78711
             (512) 427-1350
             {877} 953-5535 toll free




                         POST OFFICE BOX 12426   AUSTIN. TEXAS 78711    TEL: (512) 427-1578   FAX (512) 427-4130   TXBODA.ORG
                        IniA Ctaur^r   CAow       mo. 'ZxbC-' lH-2j0^2jO(o        f
                                                                                  x

                                           Or-"'                             XA
                              \Vc ^T#re: or            irx<A5
                                       Al>l> fcl\tc_



           C&TAwet> T(Ioav aA fitft&eST                     iAaE^WT
 To Tfre rto*#-A^LE 5u5>T\teS> op Ttte Codex oP WEALS''
   d£>fAe> (0OC>, ?tVTiTcclL \\zaJ£A(( A^CtlLA ^)fO c^. *«4 tU a(so»x- -stvLi
(Vvvl A)wAe«-cA CvAOSe- o,vA <2es^AAo|ly e^ooe^bj* 'tU*. Loo^-b X& sobb^s^
A* A. e)tUo«U^ -C*-*»v\ eu^Lu. \i *\U_ About o*ose_ "IV* -£«Alo£ioq*-
U Hvx^ £»4vf\L,maAx. lOWxW- tOr.lW. 0r ©<tA wAtcb. tvrc fcoe*boAcA 4o
   t<- wvAit by 4\-_ A^»t>rilU«cb*
"W (a.»~| fc^SxAb; 4«>v~ A,Ay c^ioA.VL 4t«>4s^ C-oAxLa* \oA a>cA lC-~Ael 4A
   •**\pes-^t\As f ic\coX e>r ofo*><- Vsb*^ o. A«w o"b*er Wsts ^ffbArel
    l«i "tVaX>   GfcS»*». }
3o Ar\l^ Aawvi pui^l ^ ^ e«,sJ^e-{ Af>^cl/Av,r's ftr/«s4 * *.A a*/ <p/w /-k**t
   Of vwJaO/wtrV^e^ otWijA *S 1U. f£&„(4 A TU. Aff«»A fitA I or <»&^r(X.
    <A iU ^WAa^V tv «yo<2M.^5 A 1U S4<AL A Tex*> „r>o> T-<- Cj rcv/rvi-s
    4WL \us *fr«*4 ^rrv UiTVHtoT ^©Sfc^LtC CAuSC *-> 1 iW- iU so^l/A..^
                                                                    AmI
    S>e<2.o»-o uaH. uj-'r^^of,^ prAi 4iUAi<-4*>rc- , v^ v/AiAo* cA 1L<_ ^oo-iS. AvA
  WWt^ Av^e-A^eA* 4o -U-c Cows-lAA-veT^ A "tU Oj.Ul <>-U4ia. *wl *wb lr
  &Ai^> ^ «4 >'\W k>*AiAAA.o A -tw S-Ut^ A Te**i. 4y £~^^j A 4w
   -LJlcXow a    4*rc4% *

                                            X
     -TU, ^^s •*> ^foUloU c*os*_ W fccrcA tor <^ <LAaU TU $>A*A~A
4rowv Oirf_\-» tuorb ^aAjsA -iV ^erAt*i Vr4Uoi><- R^aVW ioe*rc JAa4cA.




                                           [o\ -*>
                                                                 l         ^ a 4U dce&W ~
                                            -       .^-L. *A S*u-i>r<- a-»A-A'* I   •


0r«k




 L«M«WA w,TsjvA *A **"" ^
                                                ••!*•        ,         *    run,. AliccW^^



  -ft*




        vr*     v          \   i , , . . / loll A       swc\^«




       tj>(« *>*•**££*>
       \*>¥Vf ¥*A A*-<Wt4
        yj<S^jAc -Vo •Whl. wi^«^v>-v v™ — 1 ^__                                     ..
       uTw «ul W* ^ W~. Wo4 ^uA -w ^4-4v^
       vaoWVo^ A -K* 4.S.feAvA K Avv^l^^ti ^.*^«: GWs.k4vW- .A tU
       f^> ^ **V 3S.ZX *A *A ^v> oV ^ru tol*. AcVj- . W< A r«*
       wA ^A *\>«- Ai^nvA? A 1U <^JL»A- i»Ak^/ or iutvW^. ixwt^l £n
       -^X-t. fcfc»Jta*Ar W- Sofcb cct^A »wl <2*.cU><ke.d            4tTc-^ &«vi^ctu- w 4lw*
         GfcoVc ^         'U^vA -\U. SwC ci T^>c^> A-vk 'As Aoew4 ^oid^A^jj -TC
                                                         2.^>
                                                                        ,V^cvw
                                   g »v«.
                                                ^
                                            otbr\'     v. —
                                                          ^.vift-^ju - VH*?




c,obsAv*A£<z£--

                                                                                  Zol*~




                                                       J|mA - p.- ^
                                                     frw

                  ^^^r£^ "^" ;JigtYTlO^ _
 - ^A^V Ww rf i««ia« ^                            Vrts^UY i*'*""£*£ ? Scx»e-




                                                                                  >wv **)
 u~i ^lUc's &A,^ ^ ^>w'* r'\Wff°'.^^
                  gw &   Sa<
                                                                  /•
                                              /                        y^eJ vek
                                                           2-«M^" »
                               1
 "b^r (%- ^rCc^ f

      X ..V***- .tee*? \5\&rv*A- (b^ Ms* Li-l- Twle^t^^bcf>uAy

  .Jfc_^5"(a). (VwA 3^t.(w\ r , A-fro %*-. .lAv^-ivdb
      X   pceA 4Jr6^v r[L_ 4*4*i- Coo^i    tl^t ^      rx^-
  _-W_ oc^4<-eir trwy ^-jpp^l-
     r* ^Jje^i.tvJt ' fcuov/^l ftG-C ^>ro ._«*__ £©&-&*=»..^kjLc-cc^
           lO^AX 1^ CWt P^lVr^- I1-*- -£J.IdOJaM
           cko^v ^> A^ >{o§ri- JtJLiVw._.^U4l..&.^±:
          -blftc--H-.. ^©utp V
            hl^lHL-^igL7 >.>*:,^SgjS
             A^cA^-^\~B^^
      ?A~[o v^U35

            O90<0S€L-      mA^*i o^ acAoW ^&^r 2o^
              H^ C^As             lyz^ry

^._        •1/jto.oHLe. ai f\p?ejrvL   (^s6n0
          1 I'oUu \>fil*JLJr^ferl nruUtl O^VL-
                             I *t ^
                          V VDc ili- Sol8/^



       t^OT\n^ Tap- cU^irApumb &&u$ty_'$*i&_
                 /^jfe-ft^CS                                        \
ULJfaf^sc- &TKrfino*> pZc.D_.sy. ^^e^M^r_.__M.€_____
_?^I^69^1/1c170aJ_•                    --,.,•_-
 b^^J^ _>_ rtULj To. Wim&i ft»hLi__=-rs ^flJj(
 - -*A- .lAcoTlo^ -p, (4_La_jT A-ic ___<><» to _je_i_<rn>
   k^ X:Ul V ._iL -Ql J _loiy _/H^_.-tU,_.__._
   to_.y._> _>L H^p4ti^bs ^Oa-SL* '^l_^o___ yyu>ii«^_>
    U>erc     4bLl     v;^)vL__r _. I^tW. JblbO N- 2jdSz.oC
 _ Arv/s 1 _\> IX> C.vtf r. SO(gIO UvoSx_ p©*1)
                                                  0*--V~_       -K.l-L«s£J
                                                            y
    (eS3S Ct^ocb &X
     Svv^j (WAopca .Ta * *"? 8 T-ST—




       ^Cr-

                                                      pro i>e-

                         *.*£*
  m\**~A [^j-^/ AjU _                                            1
__"_>_<'g.fp   #474__»-.4 %_£teg__4v_|              ^W_*__*__~
__. J_                                   .W.HqUftSO*-
-^Lt_K4___Pcp,r!/-

     ^>        Q_   ***_
                              J.-Jwi.
     ^(i>_.--_^            _.<>/&/•- _*_^_r3-5tf_
       fe __«__ ^P<_- <fc^- Al/ffA^


                                                                 A$$^i
j^. iTeffocu b. VUU                                           N___*^'i___. lA^A^jy
   COO/A il ArppeAb>. ciiev-lfN

 W       Mr- Kyi*--,                                U- PA- IS-oo Hlo - cA


   £j\.Jut>*X ?U_s-_ L^l **f****{-$. Ph? -x_. ^f^ A^rv
  k_ k__,_-r^j An i ^«/#^«r_.t^4 a^'iih • Uj^ 'fkro^hk Af A




   A— £*        A /(Uc --tof*-*****!
                                               ^CrotC-e.. -




                                                                          %J*cl^>   s__-




                                                    ^4e.<b lU^-^itttS^
                                                     «£. ©«••^ui^JH^   \j tw\T
                                                                &
                                                      G?35T.. ..C^**ft-L_ G_L

                           ^RECEIVED N

       >9*                      NOV 3 0 2015
                            .THIRDCOUSTOFAP=EALSy
                            \     JEF..£YDKVir /
                              •£=•     .* *       V-"



                              H_f :.
                                            <_>

p
                                       •p         «___^_XtSi
                              A
                                                   I/*



    7^>
     c
        &
        p
                      c


                      4-r-
                          .




                 v    _p ^

     \
           LA
    _2     J_
                c^-       A
    -J



     V
     ~t_
