                             ^        pra$£ p,o* (S
    ,                      6}UrV C-f-      CnY>\inou| flppgJs

        Ifee^W oKfato?                             [9,-^-0050 ^rR
              AheM_
                 vL




         ikmikr^o^j^^
                                        M^" Floor )r?Mi khudae jOt) tit 9to<d«scy
£       \_        _,                    J^koTLLJKZEX

                       Q^tou- ^(KamfiH               R^QuCTbD



                       <ju±,_t          ^<W)\Q FO^Q jHOTffll/
                                        Pnach UniV t5%H^ffr)/^
                                        jchUijffl^Ji_J2aa^
                  RECEIVED IN •                           -   F!LED
             XOORrOFCRlMINAtAfPEAtS                    COOFTTOFCRIWINAL APPEALS
                       JH"tln»w            -•                WnZTrt

                 Afeet ACOSlB,Clerk                        Abel Acosta, Clerk



                                  /
           \(Qo\e   o£       fCAV^Ah                    -P^fc-

    Z^k. 0^ ft>\VcMKlVtg^
                                                        Ail
           * nfadtyyrveAJ?
                                                         9v

                                                        ^

                                                         •hst.w
                                                        id
        ~lMwrt\W    Tlargc! •J> fftufefcOcA* gm<We      lilOillWli
               \fiS fair:"OtAtei Dtoaw      VoCdU-4->   R»
•                                                       4:H
     n^mnm-/-'
                                                        lL)i6
    J^peAto,                                             15»\W
      Aab\e    o£ AuVhnriVieS           W»M                E^

 Cose?>
  ^^\aX^tsMh\^3M FSup^S5SLga                               a
rJBsbda-uiUxeo^^                                           Sv


                                                           to

£4h\m^-CQd£&ti^is^m^                                       5x
-£k yart-e. Am^^iti-^ 33*>/SW>5D 36~5t>^:
                                                           5

                                                           ^bk
 "6i/Q|fe \j. U-5, ,Me>5 u-5/ I5c>f/fi?,^ ^,#^,76^,0^      i
 51 lt2A,9A [CMfarti)
                                                           4
                                                           a
jJ^lb^JUi^
                                                           1l

" i-OZanQ i/. to^anoi^ 3UA 5DM/
                                                           a.
-fYli'fcW v/,5-fate 76^j SW^D%

 nqtoft                             .
                                                           i


'Pembroke v', \j\)ocA CbtmV-j >\g'x<x5•.^"81 f/3Q<%2Sj6W   ^
  rases                                         '

                                                           u

 ___5±jr_________,
 Therms ftSkV<? 550 SiW>elD bHi C<ft IYet 0 flpp.'/ 977)   5i
  U't)* v,chxya 735 F^D^o                                  Pi
                                                           Ok
-Ufr v^alperm MHt fraPkta                                  l°i
-U^eie reh Viou^Vi v< fYlaro ne^tt-                        <\
-U^ v.^u)ar4 ,b5 r^ wCli^Q^m^                              <\
 -VanAelft v, ^ose^ 3) F'3jr ^1* 7?7
  ' William* v.CirftvmU *W3 F.^ib^                         0
 *• Zimmerer v.^m^rlib^o ^w/.^p o?5^

   Morin men-b

 -£xKiKr\ ^ TLetter "^o "5o% GhrNV fc^rteA^j

 jraWit Rcga/Jf^ DratAiryi^ivtf- ;
 Q&\j&G^wk^^


 V\SjSl5e^Cm.\^_J0j£^_Q^^^
 —                                               ^m5-

£>fV\flb R)ftD 5e£.k5 Vo appeal V\\'^ cftavrtcKan avvi^eavence. £oe Vwe o ^.nsg^

^.tS-QcfeexiSc   (A SppVfjr^h^r d^ ftOl^ cnU a^Ver ^aVeriao^ g .f>l«.a <?f
v'r>oV- o^'\IK| \' proczedqA Vq Vtto,I \>-\ Saury \w Vh« i\4^-fNT^Vtrcf Coivf o£•
SmiVh OouA.k/lleAa45«>Xn ^Vembera£ 3oi^ 00r, fori mcus rotatete<l an*

 C0O^tne^€AK 5_y\WOf ipas pvoooanc&j. an VV\€ 3/7*^0 ^ S<yY<!jn\>er~ t^QBanc1


fiWbmiAV o^ fivQCPAar^\ lu<w^f
 Tv^TiueA&h Ch^r^ of AppSite <yp\(\von aA4_a^emeAt ujos handed
 Auua\T\ QJovua»v|•&Tt3lQfo.iNr\oVcor> £bc &,Vgjn?>ron p£ Tcme, Vo Qile moUor>

 VVme Vo ftie morion W ceWoinrt^ uoaa ovjgj-ailed <x3 vuvVctn-ely ovn
 ^^n"l<^v3>Olt3.Go^e.Qu-gAV^iy fto moHon $6c t^Ja-cxm-tv^ ujcjjo £tl€<L

 CnroanA^ Far ft^«ua.
 (Ylfv ford Sefj ^orWi foc>.r(H^) gToaAA.t) £or fto>Ceu*
(nrouM For (Vjuscuj /V7ui/\akec Qfyg.YlT):11

- \V\gL CcxicV o£     Att**As £rted t\Ts W\lCn^Jta^V„<^^
Ground For fWioc? f\)umW.r liiao fcC) 1frrrora \<\ Voir Du
- \\\£. rouu\ o-£ Appeals m WaUtn^ VvuiV Wvirt. jjqojj no errors in vdfrOfre*.
"_G\fCXJufVL for <Ww ^hvmbeT TV\f^£^J^fXr^^,^^^^^CP__
 AiumeM-                       :       ;                                      ,

  \"r> Vo Vie *xia\ucOreA u\r\\gr VW sWAaU e.v\u£(flbel \»n S^cVclarvl w
 \NJ05V\^W^ HioU U,^ u\d% xto^S.cV, v^/b^S L.&A-?>P ^HH/l<W>^cilsg


 \W^r \\\") \yca)t Coameto per£oiw\ar\ce: &g_lV NoeWj oof\ O^g-cV^e. sVo^Agutl of



 \oVod\K(« AlMnoufo do one vrtbVance oW^ fA\o>ne. fy\cv^ W gUL&Cefe/U.




 fflelvjft\ Tv^wNp^on yjoa'c) AekcCefyV ru\A       ^a\VeX "To




  Qpfi\e. a moHon To t3w press fjo^g/vfe                         ^_


^Ag^ ax\k. o^c^e. %aV w\<\ forA. isseo ftoV Yhg pg;pcA>rator vxAqp cotobei. \^i\o,(oc\^i
                                                     P(rrfrS
CjO^Wyttft \$ vftWuCfeUjeA oogV^ VesVc^ \a QoxH g<\A WxrcoJdle



^vjuQ^oCV ck. row^CcVco^ „                                                 :         .
 ft?) fciW. Vn XNMcfiHojfx,W». and Qr^covef fijuUncg ffi^ryirV^                _
 fcmeiLauXfra _ffi3StW »^Q^ ^.^(flU qfeme^ rejpexnh'n^ axrftwW



                             10^x*/i^ojA3_jo\_svy1ISO.jon°, % ^rh» lA/e^m.,,
   HIS aw ^n^ai,^               lex tc;rt-r.tPP.^clQ^.(^n ecooomrc AecfofaT) Vo
r>oA- %UA\s{ ^ug^Vt^aJy^ r^ nei\ber qLoVrdde^Ce nor rgggonaJplg. clecteft*y

 W     CVO v„uVh Wxl lAaACrj fieaprAed afoHmi/iVS a£ kflorla CocVe.5
Igfog. Q\fO i63AV*oV- flfcXrasfr \M\Vfla5 (KV^05)-6^QHiaQ 0<r Pn^frli^qVfetfr


V^or moj=> "noV sV^i\nYL iWAvnln oAso £oC\W Vo r«MjgoVcy>e a*M Pb<wer

\~> oA*>o Ey&jjAfl&W-f evj\A«nce c-£ a   5y\texnei\ f VT\c^» Vooa Vo\ co<be» gav^.
J^^„meAcaj^



  &?fo M^l-Hfl3* An attorns/ hn^ a QYo£fetoQcJ^dak(_^o_Q)g^^_
              ,                   __                P>G?ft?&



 aV flp^-^qoHiaoV PrCWik ^KuwVtyibr Ben 6^on o>#o\)67fl ~W>)
 Ofk< ~TVfry\yflcm $bo £cnUeA 4o ilnVtodupe. •Ka/Icx QirtesS aUW^4 fo
 W\g, YfleAfy (^P aUachongAV, £x\nbA O, The, DUO aftA ffaiVwcM *c

 "l)Ot 0^0 °fo Q^Vucyv? QQrl Qgt^6^7 l/VaAto ReG*A&j irQ^re^ OflPfcteXi^
  p£ XT\DJ\^ \res ^KkA ccvx,\A W a^eA Vo pirg-PX^ £r hf^l U (prrfp^rK/




A^Vda.e<LJV<o-J^AA&^^                                 \hi-^eASCi_<i&oabm^
\vy n,Wc\w a'b Viam^!- /^a ^Wm.^ Wie *5ceng as Q passenger cpg^,,
                      __^                                 ?(b^{7               __



Vook ^cv Oi WV5 Ctt\VpgJ recarAi^ mVe/ufcw qV \W> seen? oVciivyv on ^k

AW—^A^V^^oiLjOte^^
tyy^ W (XfftOrciW ua&5 nol. Oh, TW> Dv/£> uoirfr ta^U onto*? yHUcz)

________ fyuao giV 6o^5^0~HHHk<) tU3hcn astaa tea?? Yw oibkcJaf

 Vj^Cyg? Vi^T V\us>VjoaA^ ^n^e' 5feeC>voC>N) a^C\f.TrQAxny\- yo\,H ^tlo(o \\(*5rfa
 Of\pj, CoAe? N-g-A-t^ Vo W pefpcJiVrdWWc^ W_(Vk^Vojr\A ffocfof \rfc£ hir

rflffi&'hVg-flSftisfoncp rjafru pyemia OO raxfficb Q^Vare Vo ^(V? a mflVmn



 VW VQAXYvChtv^ mvten&a o^xVk Aq<»jf, W,n Ctw&ctCe.^ Vo supprt-V V)P>

 lefV \o \W nauu-t- iV t*? Wte AuV{ sV VW Aefen^ a^omeY U afremfo- Ah^mu.^

5kVe 7ka fh\MtaQ£lto. //) D'f$PrM\ fault- -~Tlur.i&u fr.ofHie. pre/salAy



Jh^pypLb<il<^\ffi&                     fob* ifatimmy.Z') ffloffW ttvuill hdMf.fc&o
JMjjgJ_~-/yPfl& JoQMpfcfi (ftjoady 'Iopm granted becaitfeDQrt- resalh rcprka neflk,
                                                       f fatty
 \p a fnaiVmA po\Y\\ cy\ Vnftqfrne-feee ^Qre^tc PStoIs^j qj& 0(] ft kooraW^/
f-PparV^, &A\oM VCCK\W,rWe MacM "TOPS         \ro^^H-^^[gn ^taaW^TVl-
 \2o%^J&b]&cpKy a? faao^aa ,oV£*n* AcNAg^liol-zp(zT)/feb mofw to 5U/P&-,

f[\(i fbi^ fib \Tlr^foif\e^'7 ^gXftpVfcp oV her ^(foWW^sie dikthtmk
?j\\ti)\\-l) 5W 50^ \s YW^ ^eAa {tt> Wcn.^ Npeo^e-f* TheeS) tvfhmies
Jo^ViNyyw.^ icrttfltoA cx\A ftUcrpAy? AyA YYVc Oqt^ l-^ a teg^t-l gay*
 DtlecctV? ^ujai Vq\\1^ WV cxid qV f(V^ W aAA <YV/ tfrrse^ -fr^f
 ip<V> Qoy-7^ i? ViH(u>nr-o^,^ T^o^eg. -T/V~W» ue\-ti pq> ^ghne^as^

 )ft\^o ^,^jY^^ee~VriTiraJA%vrol ^ 9<yl63 Uhe ^Q-^^^A <V.-^° j-o'Kfr^-•
-grat^jLaAg ^\jwc\\>er foU^^y K>»or) C^> =>WA aAcL ^roofc-f ^>ee T^Trart?,
ydV^ <p> V3fl lire 7^3^) >flbo n0f5. C^\^ "Te^VC^ W (xr^^^ ^




„pYM]^Jft©-^:V-tam-/^^


4^UAc€. tpo^W \>f, ^uHcuiaV ^0 to^toA topcoat ^iVr^e qjo^U tee,
££&^5_^V<^\Jb^
Q^Vyw8_feL_o^^

 (ftVOUAA, for fteuUio flaJftW "~\\PQ fePl! £rror^ \n Vofr Qlte.
-• \hfCfl^Aa£ A?(Hb pxreA ^ Yio^tVi^ \W voir Dfte tuos eVferfte,
                                                                PGr#°l

 ^cK.\sOh AW^KQ^mg. cauV V>^\A \W a pvo^emAc^ a^oV Ovc^fVt^jf^hfh^

 ^WtT rdice vtolare^ Wo e4jaaf p^Ucf non clause•;. ^.bon v< k:e»Auc<cy /
  M^i U.S. ^Ir^rj-, hm tan /^.^n^ri^fl-)i ~TW fl^r> h,c
 W\A \W\A remm»l Q-£ "Scfr M to\xxck uenivg w^mber^ -gsWbl^W Apr<W
_Jrflae cay o$ <~<&Q A(%jM)jK&ccn-,M^\C^^c^UiQ^ r«31 <t13/7,1 fei»,/fr<re)
JflfOAte for Rejm'eiu Aai^W "fr^" ^ l^»rwifCrr,re/t4V byiAi^g-




 o.V \W W Qtoce5^ qooA^tvto \>^ W\£ M^Am^,te\Vu4- ^ p^gon shd/be flati,
 Vo y&fa \W nvvuf) aVa CJfJVnim^ rofMrrlran gfcg.pA mpcn 5\iV£rcrmA- prerf--
 aefeneA go <&CAeA& y\goeS6tuv^J \o aswtoai aVtCo/ ctf fae^ \fcyofe afeoLgctuxJUe domM
  £>£ \\ys eft^^ci o£ w^ QkntftA-J 0-V-Hv offense» tu<kne£ <j^? c^^ccftnf


T^/fVoY^^ <x\\ek^Aiv-( r6V)W) \vqAa CfixVes mo-^ &,bedAd fe*jare<i :vajp hruto 4WlotVrf<U


\W ^tt&g. v-? r«b\ p^mVteA V> ^ve^aA- ft\W p_vi^nc^ esrpAWj pve^AWi-fi;/) s^




v* Q'ce^ieAV^ VW 9^c=eaY\oA ^.VStlo^vo^ ^«ju> Art».l ^v»()J(cui^A 0(\krV VVie. -f(\te€ k>^*V
_C^eJ\!0rV\XAp>&\ft? \c&\frto/H _^^^42. pVolecuVfttfl kwuuJ csr SV\tM^ We kywxuvi
 o£W\q Qivh(W| _^^uyv-^ pfttV^ a\usV ^uj \WV UYW^iAb ajo/efois^^t")

 Vft We (XJfec^eA ^vfrycvaAV o£VW ^, oJ\A3P) aWVV fl\o<5galVfito klTAur Muy

_g3rfrtt0Ywi tvyyg) ^oAs2 A^^_lA.- flV Obra^ »&tnVei w\A- WtrfteA VV^VWVtfivA
 ypysoeA yn^ &\W) AfoAa Cs»rVo A^uWAW- p^pcM-wiKire p\Yftrant c/eoaplrsf)
(MM ft\f,&A cWb y^V &V WckA W/fpVfoo WVffln Octrees• ,k(K/U




  r^y^ kftAft fcnyUc,. ^YAu^rA \J, sVvh <£BF\ ftWi <tn /n^/rUir- /«/U ggioita/k*

 okVaer oEfrcV £uwy beM crjmiM^_^VEl]C^ VvyW£-gtfe§afr^?
 Sdnpj>A.\-' k> be P^a0oAft^t^dAv.y\ai9g.ft> M4l &ftOkW'ft-Vitus'? yi^ be.




" kfvAft f&Vft XruvVttA V\or (te/paW o^ beftv^ Wci^ysrf rt/lA -(W>^ fa.g*gg_

 ^c<^vaI   v(_x^eA &\\caj»v»3 y^<YVA(W\fu ot- Vjl __v>erw, /Wn^-iOi-aoia^'"^
                                                                Pfr#//


  _f)Q - UffikP) »aftfy SWfreisVvtfoMW<\ \Wnfoe,r \fameJH (fr^i/ier OAA former. Sujcik?

C<w,&oto> ~^mv> fWy <ifl> htufXGtX Irato^h. y^W XWvk^A
 \\dV 4<2-La\i_ rOrt^A q^ be^v^e4 or ^cck^sae ~Tr.~[mtt?, \jo[S Q$'3M lina^-jf)

OAA ^te^.(c>vL~{r< -fm.% yo[^ ffc)laa fife. ^-gP^) VCenngf/? QrA/A^i^r 4^^frf/y^

\\(\L OayYlon ^yim WiSpy*. \VuV ^tV^ Mr, toonA ^ ft^y -fa/-
fflft CWw ?^ tifV. Wfy4- O-VfrW W°k Wefo^f s)1)1 fey ^Hfe^ 46^ru?




$&smJ£b#—*>)<ki^
 fa**.\foi-y pcj.zv Kw n-df^ V> p^,6l lev*. ViQ .5)»>ifa/ /Qhri for/ifou
%ckA \\e \\P^er\Wyr ^ \T> air W- a qWloxf <y -Sav^AbX^ CisaqyeA ftAotAfl^

 V.<pcy\^.CVv^ C^fe^o- o£ \W co^c toft-"? a \Wv\ <y^ &AA hi <ftc\A_ OftYYvXyo Vl^
Ny.o^ (Hoc. Tvro^. sio^n pgy'aa \Cne^-o>)'K^V^to^S V-et>Vefoe> KhkHheiru^
Wo ^^i,^ on coqt rOae. Q\0jCv^ VokWu Q\ Vbz&u&pr ^eoJ^ (7Trc7rouT$ ,l/o/<7
 p^ i14 Uir\£"5ff7*ftfc ^Vq. &q>MV dg^c>>e. J.tlv^^Tr«TQn9.Vrd(>7p^i, /o/ //in.

ura> TioV q_ veflVV VA ^»-(WV vtoo^ Wocm^h^ aA^ 5Vx:W^ i^ IraA^VoU^p^4.°k_
  Va^b V p^\on Y-1^7 W^V \?uA- ycA \e<feV "^^ 0®%-{ ie5Vvfe^ ^ hv^ p^rccLJ
          1     ______                                          f>6>&/^




 /VW/IWy _foftfri /W- /^ ^ over/raw He pa9m<pr$ ye#4- Mk> ih JDhU>,<? ?&<<+
 .W Vxl arrusftj, /TV, (h(&o£ tfMty cjJ^^ Qyhes? Seal gd^uoeslJ- jfl r<\hb /f/fi,6»h*

  fiWfilLctf dcXUpV^i oVWt (WfJolflfeir CuhzH tf\f, f5rA does Hoi-Q-L df^/flr, £tkV &*s
 qftA by ^ ?&? o£ ^%i<v/»- flIVq. Carle? 3aU he/ pe/pgjrnLhr am Fh. QmtAA. Q* #//

 oV fp\)b^ VfoiU. qirVE9 OOft? &fo t/Vlr/ /Wy•/H/fteJ fi'hwLf jnj\*A& a/L*Jki.
 VYVr» Jp6r3eV rt ftc *ck*( pyptLUhr ah,-nbte /Hr* On4& l(k(mJatiJ J??lff<{f)u



  frV/ Oopfrxp fykfe/nm^ ujo5 nnakn^/ beamy pr&bubfl^/ evfiif'^nh.

  ^A^ TraL ^.^'(teatto taw ar qhaufriW faou^ /^>-£kia^WfrwL
 -(JL^JV£.hVtm(m^_cjo.Q^_J^^ -PreXaUgcu \\Y\^p or^Vvjj^\Y0^ fcviuuw Of\n
   ^6 ^y^<y>ckVi>) ^ -^ c^eA^ rexiY^ u)h^h \W^Te ft" a cop^ o£6t<hlbi$r-
\\!U P^JpaVvcLW as> Y\£aJ>0€A' ^ro^.cai<^ 0^\?7© Y<v\e>^ oC SYioh,VACtc iCVUs^^ OOrcOe^Y^
                                                              J______

(AW; oVAccJ recowkA jnVg-fure^ VhoJr WroJra.c(rer qjojo KtoV ^tox/v^cjJh^o
cjli<^Vcwe^*6x-e Q^Q. cavkc^ tWeAtaSH NMUy^ ^d3))5^047510 or Re/>


VYV>H' tuflftsfV crvVy Wv^leAy aVMno. $ft\ftg Wfgvisc; ^mcfo kflooifetiq^ ^ f//7
Vff WYvQvAr^^ Vo ^V<?yW prove a kr*? aV^D Cmdu*) Jino/YPn, CorJk*?'?


  Mteate fi*f\> ch^-e^        ;v\VW    A$_ fcbV)W^/ o~V /Dry <2rrte
 <bWi \Vk/\A (Yv> rt^AdS^ Qoe^ r)o4- V(V AV\2 okxrfpi-rfro o-f Wr?/

fcoi<kfl» proves VWi- lT)r<Qrefrft Ateme/iA a^A tehynay da.ay^j ffinFwfl

_JpfUJffr fc^n^ JWW feii/P-h !(\»nW /trr-eft k fo(irl<
 ~6SttecteMc(/ o-fffcT^fe jpr^ow oftorfe vrWafei /77rv f^i? Pup pro-a?ss? crghf*£


 flTffty? Vo a JOJUJ JiW/l/ (V\ki-?± P&iblftL) ~Tx>o ikiwj\h I) The actosS




Al^J^
W V> qhc(xuc ojiVAii^ Vs) vto *5e brfek fifm FcfrA ujco tay/\ctA ace*?? £ ^
          J.                                                 ft?#/y


OV Qdjq&k Lvf\\)0\)Jr fY\r/fgife. pro se brfeP. %_) '^eUQfjjMtkjXCZes') CaaSeA
\\iYn ftL\ofli info*/-Du& k Ifa deprmiw 0^ kw lihra^f ^wnmi or)


 Via? re^VUi m %5f ^?rrfod^ ^/(/(y -h> o/?(y argue hese po-fth



    W Ao\(Ce Z/Art fed flat &e* etchltety pastfuy h'~J eiPfteulfartd.ca5e.i W^G^
 ¥\\&) all /VTo4ron-> ayu cfioittn-? §* e*to*y offline Jhal he. ha.? hiauikty*.

 eJfocr*!' n* Ha fo/>, rTlr/<&r± Wc0Ye tk fafopsuA o-f-fifflwk UiM*
     {he m hi*? mohfa? ftleJ, -fir Qckn&n? at hh ^ p*epa/r </-&& his 1


 CM'tyl ftWtety rtifow^ h<u-ei m,,^ r/^kU &i<l-ne,tes wf-hb
 pnA,K<f {totfiilddf h f!)r, &J flO^T? -/^ ^      dJ^juahs (D&y^LJzaAJ^


 ^^Lavt^:^^^.^^
  $(^e/ V^r \^drc(^

_4fe_a[U^ifcfi£Ub_42teia^^
     ••                    •                       Pd?# 7$
C&\$kul\£ a£ SevYiue                                           :
 Ti£^ya?o fWO v^o Vvi/rpVv/ cMrty VVtg^oi We &.(Y oxrtcj


    VV QxuA o£ CuYi\im,( Appmb <\V- PtQ*fex i^^c^ifli(prk{Sk^
lfivUoVmf Tegto T^mi \ Vo VW> prolocutor, QA ftq*Kil .ftln(rifcho^/S'^^-
OV H Floor tGw\\b\>se. 1QQ (Vt ^oaAoj^j TijVg^TX ^-90^ n^A



                                        Defmdcuii ftp Se.




                                     Onto**, Ti nq&ol

        CoaA o^
 ^^%J^^^q^^^s^\^ Q^mcLoj?                             _3cxsl


                <\jg,ta~)> 0030*3-0^
                ^w\o-^i(h^if>^)ftn
                        ftppelM

                 "The sVafe o£        (exaa
                        j^pj__t_
                :                      ;          pM¥k>
~~^\\t> QQQd^ lamg. \o be. heari. on \W, c^y&<nfai/g-oecocj a^
\)Ue£ fi\ei Werm QAx VW sein^u beft^ comiAire^gV t? VW ^fn/m?


AV fin <w4 teioLu be. ft 4il VWty d^Wi&i l ante Ahi-l 4Vul

 ftttteA cgYipfoV-eA "o-C \<Mcr^ftoi CvS,^ y\o\/ie13'ognA fWJey ,^*
     £m*tir                          _Ex\b\V X-




Photo: Tevin Montravian Dorsey/Smith County Jail Records



Information from Tyler Police




Original Story: Early Friday morning, at about 5:05 am, Tyler Police were called to the Shiloh Pines Mobile Home
Park in Tyler in reference to the reported robbery of an individual.
Officers contacted the victim, who said that moments after arriving home she was confronted in her driveway by a
younger black male wearing a grey shirt and black jeans. The victim said the suspect immediately pointed a gun at
her and demanded money. He then took the victim's purse and fled the scene as a passenger in a light blue sedan.


The victim was not injured during the incident and described the suspect as heavy set and in his early 20s, with a
blue bandana covering his facing.


Anyone with information about the suspects Involved in this crime are urged to contact the Tyler Police Department,
at 903-531-1000, or Crimestoppers, at 903-597-CUFF (903-597-2833).


Crimestoppers will pay up to $1,000 for information that leads to the arrest and charges filed against the suspects in
this case, or any, felony case.
 Qgcxr ^>A^g QryisYi Wenne^f ,

OAVllO rtiiyni Vo<LQl X fa^ be^r? \xpan uxuHMikJ back ^m TOC~S
}&£)&& S- ^nq gn AppectlrZL> Vljed rj 'Tfofto'j J*\ th turf (-toang on .k?.




"~Pa7 ik /nofov &f eftw,f&? p-flfoe iXl i^p k!n*-j ft inn, bench (juoumutleJ            ._
blCfr jo \\\<u /gully /|W J£ kruje clccpt* -k qIcvu/ libnuy <n\Aioedhh &retfe^
vwvrTrcsil TyrMXrtyk Thu^ yr?*4i<>'1 /o a f^^Xdocame/i'L^cvifb fryJrutfm?

gcce^ k> omY-/ \eyIttwkxtiJ p& foA/Tbe ^tyffh raaiA^y Jar/ P 'Duppb^eJ ^prm/h




bee/) \wtc <x\tomfa \jjauftW* 7\^q^^_\\q^^
Ao vw«J*W- W ybvtW u/i W Viape^ v^Or XW. \«$A. waVenif Irv^Yoe^ \upi*teA. \o (?o^, 36
                                       NO. 12-13-00308-CR


                             IN THE COURT OF APPEALS


                  TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT

                                          TYLER, TEXAS


DA VID EUGENE FORD,                                              APPEAL FROM THE 114TH
APPELLANT


V.                                                       §       JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT


THE STA TE OF TEXAS,
APPELLEE                                                 §       SMITH COUNTY, TEXAS

                                       MEMORANDUM OPINION
                                                PER CURIAM

        David Eugene Ford appeals his conviction for aggravated robbery with a deadly weapon.
Ajury found him guilty and assessed punishment at thirty years ofimprisonment. Appellant's
counsel filed a motion to withdraw and a brief in support of that motion in compliance with
Anders v. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S. Ct. 1396, 18 L. Ed. 2d 493 (1967) and Gainous v.
State, 436 S.W.2d 137 (Tex. Crim. App. 1969). We affirm.


                            Analysis Pursuant to Anders v. California

        Appellant's counsel filed a brief in compliance with Anders and Gainous, stating that he
has diligently reviewed the appellate record and is of the opinion that the record reflects no
reversible error upon which an appeal can be predicated. He further relates that he is well
acquainted with the facts in this case. In compliance with Anders, Gainous, and High v. State,
573 S.W.2d 807 (Tex. Crim. App. 1978), Appellant's brief presents a chronological summation
ofthe procedural history ofthe case, and further states that Appellant's counsel is unable to raise
any arguable issues for appeal.1 We have considered counsel's brief and conducted our own

         1Counsel for Appellant has certified that he provided Appellant with a copy ofthis brief. Appellant was
given time to file his own brief in this cause. The time for filing such abrief has expired, and we have not received
a pro se brief.
independent review of the record. We have found no reversible error. See Bledsoe v. State, 178
S.W.3d 824, 826-27 (Tex. Crim. App. 2005).


                                                 Conclusion

        As required, Appellant's counsel has moved for leave to withdraw. See In re Schulman,
252 S.W.3d 403, 407 (Tex. Crim. App. 2008) (orig. proceeding); Stafford v. State, 813 S.W.2d
503, 511 (Tex. Crim. App. 1991). We carried the motion for consideration with the merits.
Having done so and finding no reversible error, Appellant's counsel's motion to withdraw is
hereby granted, and the trial court's judgment is affirmed. See In re Schulman, 252 S.W.3d at
408-09.

          Counsel has a duty to, within five days of the date of this opinion, send a copy of the
opinion and judgment to Appellant and advise him of his right to file a petition for discretionary
review. See TEX. R. APP. P. 48.4; In re Schulman, 252 S.W.3d at 411 n.35. Should Appellant
wish to seek further review of this case by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, he must either
retain an attorney to file a petition for discretionary review or he must file a pro se petition for
discretionary review. Any petition for discretionary review must be filed within thirty days from
the date of this opinion or the date the last timely filed motion for rehearing is overruled by this
court. See Tex. R. App. P. 68.2. Any petition for discretionary review must be filed with the
clerk for the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals along with the rest of the filings in the case. See
TEX. R. APP. P. 68.3(a).           Any petition for discretionary review should comply with the
requirements ofRule 68.4 ofthe Texas Rules ofAppellate Procedure. See Tex. R. App. P. 68.4;
In re Schulman, 252 S.W.3d at 408 n.22.
Opinion delivered February 27, 2015.
Panel consisted of Worthen, C.J., Hoyle, J., andNeeley, J.




                                             (DO NOT PUBLISH)
                                COURT OF APPEALS

     TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT OF TEXAS

                                         JUDGMENT


                                       FEBRUARY 27, 2015



                                       NO. 12-13-00308-CR



                                    DAVID EUGENE FORD,
                                               Appellant
                                                   V.
                                    THE STATE OF TEXAS,
                                                Appellee


                               Appeal from the 114th District Court
                        of Smith County, Texas (Tr.Ct.No. 114-1281-12)

                   THIS CAUSE came to be heard on the appellate record and brief filed herein,
and the same being considered, it is the opinion of the court that there was no error in the
judgment.

                   It is therefore ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that the judgment of
the court below be in all things affirmed, and that the decision be certified to the court below
for observance.

                   By per curiam opinion.
                   Panel consisted of Worthen, C.J., Hoyle, J., andNeeley, J.
V'
                                   -p&Q
                              9 <=£ P       :!i S




                                        *
                              o




       m




      i
      m




     ______'


     —*4i
 -is



 S&
 — "{)
               ?
               ^r
               ^«—:

     ;«'.•     JS
 •'•&:
 •-^
 at-
               ^
      Hi
                #
               ?<     so o
     •^'
               fi
                      eft £

 •I • ^ €



                      3
